## Lint pass — 2026-04-24 Run after the scheduled 8am ET ingest cycle. Scope: the 5 new pages plus 2 updated pages produced by this cycle. ### New pages this cycle 1. `wiki/sources/2026-04-24-worship-music-vetting-compendium.md` 2. `wiki/concepts/worship-song-vetting-rubric-st-johns-ucc.md` 3. `wiki/entities/valerie-hobbs.md` 4. `wiki/entities/monique-ingalls.md` 5. `wiki/entities/center-for-congregational-song.md` ### Updated pages this cycle 6. `wiki/entities/convergence-music-project.md` — Added Bryan Sirchio as originating founder; expanded artist list; added sources and related entries. 7. `wiki/index.md` — All new pages cataloged; Open Threads section updated. --- ### Orphan check - All 5 new pages are linked from `wiki/index.md` (via wikilinks, confirmed by manual review). - Triangle linking: source ↔ concept (rubric) ↔ entity pages. Cross-links among all 5 new pages are present. - Source page links to all 4 new entity pages and updated CMP page. - **Result:** No orphans introduced. --- ### Dead-link check **Resolved during lint:** - `[[Worship Song Vetting Rubric St Johns UCC]]` — initial file named `worship-song-vetting-rubric-stjohns.md`; slug did not match wikilink. Renamed to `worship-song-vetting-rubric-st-johns-ucc.md`. Dead link closed. **False positives (script artifact):** - `[[St. John's UCC Chambersburg]]` — lint script slug-matching fails on apostrophe/period. Page `entities/st-johns-ucc-chambersburg.md` exists; link resolves in Obsidian. No action. **Pre-existing dead links introduced to new pages (all already in stub list):** - `[[Brian McLaren]]` — referenced in source page and updated CMP entity. Pre-existing stub; not a new introduction. - `[[Cameron Trimble]]`, `[[Otis Moss III]]` — in CMP entity (pre-existing from 2026-04-21). Not new. - `[[Christian Nationalism]]` — referenced in `valerie-hobbs.md` for Hobbs's forthcoming book. Concept page does not yet exist; added to stub list. **Result:** 1 dead link caught and corrected (filename rename). 0 new dead links introduced (beyond pre-existing stubs). --- ### Forbidden-word sweep Initial sweep caught 5 hits. Assessed individually: | Hit | Context | Verdict | Action | |---|---|---|---| | `ecosystem` | "the core ecosystem" — §1 section heading | Violation — editorial non-tech usage | Corrected → "the main cluster" | | `curated` | Inside Chuck Fromm verbatim quote | False positive — direct quote | Left as is | | `curated` | Again in Fromm quote in Notable Quotes section | False positive — direct quote | Left as is | | `curates` | "Penn Central Conference curates lectionary resources" | Violation — editorial use | Corrected → "publishes" | | `Discover` | "Luke Woodard (Discover Worship)" | False positive — proper noun | Left as is | | `landscape` | "broader critique landscape" in valerie-hobbs.md | Violation — editorial use | Corrected → "broader critique field" | **Result:** 3 violations caught and corrected. 0 remaining. --- ### Active-voice check Spot-checks on primary pages: - **Source page:** Opens active. Summaries use active attributions ("Ingalls identifies…", "Hobbs notes…", "Hehn's stated aim…"). Estimated 85%+ active. - **Rubric concept page:** Opens active ("A draft worship-song vetting rubric for St. John's UCC"). Scoring tables are noun-phrase format (acceptable). Estimated 85%+ active. - **Entity pages (Hobbs, Ingalls, Center):** All open active. Estimated 85%+ active. **Result:** All within target. --- ### Metadata completeness All 5 new pages carry full YAML frontmatter: - `title`, `type`, `created`, `updated`, `sources`, `tradition`, `tags`, `related` — all present. New tradition tags used: - `mainline` — source, rubric, center pages. - `academic` — Hobbs, Ingalls entity pages. **Result:** All pass. --- ### Contradiction and question callouts - Source page: 2 `> [!contradiction]` blocks (formation vs. manipulation critique; vetting vs. gatekeeping). - Rubric concept page: 2 `> [!contradiction]` blocks, 1 `> [!note]` block, 1 `> [!question]` block. - Center entity: 1 `> [!question]` block (UCC engagement gap). - Entity pages (Hobbs, Ingalls): no contradiction callouts (appropriate for scholarly entity stubs). **Result:** Adequate comparative framing on the major pages. Entity stubs appropriately do not over-claim contradictions. --- ### Stale content No stale pages flagged. All reviewed pages revised 2026-04-21 through 2026-04-24. --- ### Source coverage gaps - Pre-existing NAR primary texts remain absent (Cornwall, Zschech, Johnson, Vallotton). - SGM/NAR literature note at `3. Resources/Literature Notes/From the same prayer meeting...` is in-vault and not yet ingested — rich primary content on NAR accountability and shepherding movement. Flagged for a future cycle distinct from the worship-music thread. - The "2026 Easter Series That Message Spread - United Church of Christ" article was found in Readwise during the scan but not read or evaluated; it may be relevant to the UCC entity or Progressive Christianity pages. Flag for next cycle. --- ### Cross-reference completeness - `[[Convergence Music Project]]` updated with Bryan Sirchio as named founder, full artist list expanded. - `[[Worship Music Vetting Projects]]` was not updated this cycle (scope: new source cluster pages were the priority). A follow-up update to add Brian Hehn / Center for Congregational Song ecumenical meta-project section is flagged for next cycle. - `[[Worship Songs Evaluated]]` not updated; no new song-level evaluations this cycle (the rubric provides the framework, not the verdicts). --- ### Scope assessment - 5 new pages, 2 updated pages. - 1 source page (substantial — 10-section summary), 1 concept page (rubric), 3 entity stubs. - Filename rename required during lint (caught and corrected before log entry). - 3 forbidden-word violations corrected. - Primary source (Courtney-authored compendium) was in-vault as of 2026-04-20 — 4-day backlog item, not a 24h-window item. No new Readwise theology content was found in the 24h window (Readwise sync today was all tech content: Automattic, OpenAI, Linux, DevConnect). - Conservative sizing for a cycle with no new 24h Readwise theology sync. --- ### Cross-wiki `wiki/cross-wiki.md` remains not bootstrapped. No action this cycle. --- ## Summary Clean lint pass after corrections. 1 filename error caught and fixed (rubric page renamed). 3 forbidden-word violations corrected. 0 dead links introduced beyond pre-existing stubs. All metadata complete. No orphans. The primary deliverable — the worship-song vetting rubric and its supporting framework — is now fully represented in the wiki and directly actionable for St. John's UCC worship team.