# Theology, Deconstruction & Faith Formation Wiki — Index This index catalogs every page in the wiki. The LLM updates it on every ingest. > [!tip] New to this topic? > [[start-here-new-apostolic-reformation|Concerned About the New Apostolic Reformation? Start Here]] — beginner entrance page (guide, new 2026-07-20): plain-language NAR definition, network mechanics, risk mechanisms, church-evaluation framework, conversation guidance, and safeguarding basics, linked to the wiki's strongest sources. ## Entities ### People & Authors - [[john-collins|John Collins]] — ex-Branham-movement researcher; williambranham.org; hosts *William Branham Historical Research* / *Leaving the Message* / *Revival Exposed*; now anchors 16 ingested sources; archival-primary method with stated legal boundaries; lineage claims held provisionally (new 2026-09-04) - [[Ben Armstrong]] — Bethel prophetic ministry director; first *Unpunishable* case study; restored after grooming a woman in his care; case unraveling Feb 2026 (new 2026-05-26) - [[Sean Feucht]] — charismatic worship leader and Christian-nationalist activist ("Let Us Worship"); first appears in a $250k donor-fraud suit; DARVO/standing/"association of churches" accountability dodge (new 2026-06-26) - [[Greg Locke]] — Global Vision Bible Church (Mt. Juliet TN); independent-charismatic, deliverance/spiritual-warfare/Christian-nationalist; enters via a self-published federal-raid + finances-investigation **claim** (uncorroborated; persecution reframe); single-source-claim + persecution-reframe case study (new 2026-07-20) - [[Bill Johnson]] — Bethel Redding founder; *When Heaven Invades Earth*; modalism/adoptionism flags - [[Brian Houston]] — Hillsong founder; resigned 2022; Frank Houston concealment case (stub) - [[brian-simmons|Brian Simmons]] — lead translator of [[The Passion Translation]]; Stairway Ministries; NAR-adjacent; New Tribes/Wycliffe training claim disputed by mission director (new 2026-06-09) - [[Brian Wren]] — British progressive hymn writer; "Christ Is Alive" (stub) - [[Charles Fox Parham]] — father of modern Pentecostalism; trained William J. Seymour; origins-critique node (Pentecostalism → Latter Rain → NAR); stub from single polemical source (new 2026-06-09) - [[Mike Winger]] — evangelical discernment teacher; assembled the multi-scholar "Passion Project" TPT review; "TPT, Bethel, Bill Johnson all connected" thesis (new 2026-06-09) - [[Holly Pivec]] — evangelical author/apologist; *A New Apostolic Reformation?* (with Geivett); NAR critique; cold-reading-vs-demonic-power framing of prophetic/occult claims (new 2026-06-18) - [[Minor Prophets Podcast]] — continuationist discernment channel (host "John Mark" + David Fish); traceable TPT plagiarism source-trails; "Jenga tower of trust" thesis (new 2026-06-21) - [[Caroline Saxton]] — Pastor of St. John's UCC Chambersburg; updated 2026-05-11 with May 10 sermon analysis (NL444; anti-domination gospel; "unity not uniformity"; Habitat for Humanity thread opened) - [[Sweet Honey in the Rock]] — Black women's a cappella ensemble; founded 1973 by Bernice Johnson Reagon; spirituals, freedom songs; interpretive frame for Acts 16 sermon at St. John's UCC (new 2026-04-27) - [[Carl Lentz]] — Former Hillsong NYC pastor; dismissed 2020 (stub) - [[danny-silk|Danny Silk]] — Bethel; *Culture of Honor* (2009), *Unpunishable* (2019); chaired Welton's restoration board (conflict of interest) (new 2026-05-26) - [[Darlene Zschech]] — Hillsong worship pastor 1996–2007; *Extravagant Worship* (stub) - [[Harold Eberle]] — Worldcast Ministries; *Systematic Theology for the New Apostolic Reformation* (Father-Son theology, Wagner-endorsed); probable Welton restoration-board member (new 2026-05-26) - [[Jann Aldredge-Clanton]] — Progressive Baptist composer; inclusive-language hymn collections (stub) - [[Joel Richardson]] — end-times author/filmmaker; told Welton he should not be in ministry; a point of internal NAR pushback (new 2026-05-26) - [[Jonathan Welton]] — Welton Academy founder; *Eyes of Honor* / *Raptureless*; clergy sexual abuse 2013–2018; self-described "wolf"; *Unpunishable* case study (new 2026-05-26) - [[Kelly Latimore]] — American Catholic iconographer; Byzantine-influenced iconography centering marginalized faces (LGBTQ+ martyrs, immigrants, disabled, diverse global church); Pentecost icon used in St. John's UCC May 2026 bulletin; progressive mainline and Catholic contexts (new 2026-05-24) - [[Bryan Sirchio]] — UCC pastor; Convergence Music Project founder; *The 6 Marks of Progressive Christian Worship Music* (new 2026-04-25) - [[Brian Hehn]] — Center for Congregational Song director; ecumenical CCLI meta-list coordinator; UCC gap contact (new 2026-04-25) - [[Kathryn Ritsema Roelofs]] — Reformed / Calvin Institute worship leader; CCLI-vetting contributor; worship-for-workers writer (new 2026-04-22) - [[Monique Ingalls]] — Baylor ethnomusicologist; *Singing the Congregation*; five modes of congregating; formation critique of CWM (new 2026-04-24) - [[Valerie Hobbs]] — Sheffield linguist; theolinguistics; simulated intimacy; manipulation critique of Hillsong/Bethel worship (new 2026-04-24) - [[C. Peter Wagner]] — Missiologist; coined "New Apostolic Reformation"; Fuller Seminary professor; second-Reformation theory; seven mountains / dominionism; died 2016 (new 2026-05-02) - [[Leif Hetland]] — Global Mission Awareness; "father heart" apostolic teacher; Welton-book endorser (new 2026-05-26) - [[Michael Brown]] — charismatic apologist (*The Line of Fire* / AskDrBrown); invoked by Welton as parallel "persecution" (tu quoque) (new 2026-05-26) - [[Mike Bickle]] — IHOPKC founder; 24/7 prayer model; 2023 abuse investigation; full development pending primary-source ingest (stub, new 2026-05-01) - [[Kris Vallotton]] — Bethel, self-identified prophet, Trump reelection prophecy case (stub) - [[Miriam Therese Winter]] — Medical Mission Sister; composer; *Joy Is Like the Rain*; Hartford Seminary - [[Norman Wirzba]] — Duke Divinity theologian; *Love's Braided Dance* (stub) - [[Paula Gooder]] — British NT scholar; "resurrection as rebellion" (stub) - [[Randy Clark]] — Global Awakening founder; 1994 Toronto Blessing figure; Welton's early abuse pattern in his orbit (~2009–2010) (new 2026-05-26) - [[Scott Aniol]] — Reformed-Baptist worship theologian; G3 Ministries; cessationist critique of NAR worship - [[Sisters of Charity of New York]] — 209-year-old Catholic women's order; 2023 unanimous dissolution vote; "finishing well" case study (new 2026-04-23) - [[Shawn Bolz]] — Bethel-orbit prophetic minister; words-of-knowledge; wrote *Unpunishable* foreword; key [[Fallible Prophecy]] example (new 2026-05-26) - [[Steven Furtick]] — Elevation Church founder; modalism allegation; SBC-affiliated (stub) - [[Wayne Grudem]] — evangelical systematic theologian; *The Gift of Prophecy* (stub) - [[Yvonne Delk]] — UCC minister, educator, and civil rights activist; author of *Afro-Christian Convention*; Black liberation theology framing; names white ecclesiology as vehicle of racism; recovers Afro-Christian worship as gift to the UCC (new 2026-05-08; stub) - [[Dan McClellan]] — biblical scholar; "data over dogma" public educator; historical-critical method vs. popular apologetics; developing-monotheism, pseudepigraphy, rapture-as-recent positions; critical-scholarship counterweight to apostolic epistemology (new 2026-06-11) - [[Lou Engle]] — NAR-adjacent revival/prayer leader; TheCall, JHOP/Bound4Life; "Elijah Revolution"/Jezebel-Jehu framing with Che Ahn; revival-as-political-rally pattern (new 2026-06-11; source-caution) - [[Cindy Jacobs]] — NAR prophetic-movement "general"; Generals International; spiritual-warfare intercession; credited as a funder of the Firefly investigation into IHOPKC (new 2026-06-11; source-caution) - [[Che Ahn]] — NAR apostle; Harvest International Ministry / Harvest Rock; Lou Engle associate; "Jezebel" rhetoric aimed at named political figures; apostolic-authority → Christian nationalism link (new 2026-06-11; source-caution) - [[Bob Scott]] — discernment commentator; "guru model" structural critique of charismatic prophecy (single-mediator authority, media-conferred rank, competitive escalation); mirror of [[Apostolic Authority]] (new 2026-06-11) - [[Tamice Spencer-Helms]] — progressive / Black liberation / womanist theologian (TNE podcast); whiteness-as-relational-logic, "better logics" refusal ethic ("not opting into the logics"), supremacy-lives-in-the-body embodiment; biographical specifics flagged for confirmation (new 2026-06-15; stub) - [[Rachel Kessler]] — author of *Nerd Faith*; progressive/apophatic; certainty-as-danger, divine unknowability, "chaotic good" values-over-rules; Book of Common Prayer baptismal language (Anglican/Episcopal lean unconfirmed) (new 2026-06-17; stub, source-caution) - [[Monte Mader]] — ex-Christian-nationalist insider turned social-media educator (~2.6M following); militant Wyoming ranch upbringing, purity-culture harm, "let the Bible be messy" method; two *Data Over Dogma* primary sources; closes the long-open dead-link stub (new 2026-07-05) - [[Chris Coons]] — US Senator (D-DE), Yale Divinity; mainline/progressive faith-and-politics voice; "the Bible is not a political document" but carries a preference for the poor; whole-context reading vs. proof-texting; counter-case to Christian nationalism from inside faith language (new 2026-07-05; stub) ### Movements & Traditions - [[IHOPKC]] — International House of Prayer Kansas City; Mike Bickle founded; Harp and Bowl model; 24/7 prayer-and-worship; DARVO patterns documented; 2023 Bickle abuse investigation; organizational collapse (new 2026-05-01) - [[New Apostolic Reformation]] — NAR; charismatic movement claiming restored offices of apostle and prophet; now cross-linked to worship-music network - [[Potter's House Christian Fellowship Ministries]] — Pentecostal church-planting network; Wayman Mitchell, split from Foursquare ~1983; high-control case study (onefold "apostle" authority, rules-as-boundary, fear/guilt retention, family invasion) (new 2026-06-21) ### Institutions & Churches - [[spring-of-hope-ministries|Spring of Hope Ministries]] — prayer-and-counseling ministry, Waynesboro/Shippensburg/Chambersburg PA; enters via Wayne Kuhns's involvement with [[world-harvest-outreach|World Harvest Outreach (Chambersburg)]]; inner-healing/deliverance vocabulary (Elijah House / Restoring the Foundations / Theophostic family); **stub, needs primary-source verification** (new 2026-09-04) - [[Afro-Christian Convention (body)]] — historically Black predecessor denomination of the UCC (merged 1957); brought African-rooted worship (preaching/singing from African chants; shouting from African dance; "feeling aspect of religion") as gift to the UCC; Yvonne Delk primary source (new 2026-05-08; stub) - [[Bethel Church]] — Redding, CA; Bill Johnson; Bethel Music; BSSM; NAR-adjacent - [[Calvin Institute of Christian Worship]] — CRC/RCA-adjacent academic-pastoral institute at Calvin University; CCLI-vetting hub (new 2026-04-22) - [[Christian Feminism Today]] (EEWC-CFT) — feminist progressive Christian organization; publisher of inclusive-language liturgy and hymnody resources; eewc.com (new 2026-04-25) - [[Center for Congregational Song]] — Outreach arm of The Hymn Society; Brian Hehn director; ecumenical CCLI meta-list project; UCC participation gap identified (new 2026-04-24) - [[Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee)]] — early Pentecostal denomination; A. J. Tomlinson first general overseer; documented as an origin node for "centralized sacred authority"; Roy Davis/Klan/Straton/Winrod links; proto–Seven Mountains (new 2026-06-21; single critic source, disputed) - [[Convergence Music Project]] — Progressive worship-music curation; Bryan Sirchio (UCC) founder; McLaren, Trimble, Moss III co-founders (updated 2026-04-24) - [[Elevation Church]] — Charlotte, NC; Furtick; SBC-affiliated but charismatic-adjacent (stub) - [[G3 Ministries]] — Reformed-Baptist ministry network; Josh Buice and Scott Aniol (stub) - [[Hillsong]] — Sydney-based megachurch network; Brian Houston founded; Carl Lentz scandal - [[Maverick City Music]] — Worship collective; heterogeneous NAR-network adjacency (stub) - [[Modern Reformation]] — Reformed-Lutheran confessional journal; Michael Horton (stub) - [[Reformed Worship]] — CRC quarterly worship magazine; convergence-blended-worship publishing venue (new 2026-04-22) - [[St. John's UCC Chambersburg]] — UCC, Keystone Conference, PA; Courtney's worship team - [[United Church of Christ]] — Denominational home of St. John's; congregationalist mainline-progressive; "united and uniting" (founded 1957; ecumenism + cultural pluralism context added from Gunnemann 2026-05-10) - [[United Methodist Church Discipleship Ministries]] — Official UMC agency; *Congregational Song* vetting project (new 2026-04-22) ## Concepts - [[restoration-narrative|Restoration Narrative]] — the claim to be recovering the true New Testament church after long corruption; the frame under which [[Apostolic Authority]], [[Latter Rain]] and [[seven-mountain-mandate|Seven Mountain Mandate]] become sayable; converts novelty into legitimacy, turns dissent into evidence, concentrates authority, licenses recruitment from adjacent churches; Collins's chain (Reformation → Awakenings → Holiness → Welsh → Azusa → Branhamism → Latter Rain → Charismatic → NAR) plus four diagnostic questions; counter-observation is the length of the chain itself (new 2026-09-04) - [[DARVO]] — Deny/Attack/Reverse Victim and Offender; Jennifer Freyd's manipulation-pattern framework; structural analysis of high-control religious harm; betrayal trauma context; IHOPKC as case study (new 2026-05-04) - [[Dominionism]] — Seven Mountain Mandate; NAR political-theological framework; Wagner; seven cultural spheres; relationship to Apostolic Authority, Five-Fold Ministry, and Christian Nationalism (new 2026-05-04) - [[CCLI Reporting and Royalty Flow]] — Copyright licensing infrastructure for worship music; CCLI license types; royalty flow to Bethel/Hillsong/Elevation; Top 100 data limitations; OneLicense; practical guidance for St. John's UCC (new 2026-05-06) - [[Decisional Conversion]] — Evangelical/revivalist doctrine of conversion as dateable individual decision; Finney's origins; NAR amplification; progressive UCC counter-model ("conversion as draft"); Caroline Saxton's Acts preaching (new 2026-05-06) - [[Musical Sacramentality]] — Technical term for the P&W claim that music mediates divine presence; Reformed and progressive critiques; pastoral-exclusion implications for grief, disability, deconstruction (new 2026-05-05) - [[Word-and-Table Liturgy]] — Mainline fourfold shape (Gathering, Word, Table, Sending); ecumenical roots; contrast with P&W architecture; UCC practice at St. John's; DEIB lens on presence-as-gift (new 2026-05-05) - [[Covenant Renewal Worship]] — Reformed five-movement liturgy (Call, Consecration, Instruction, Communion, Commission) derived from Exodus 19–24; positive alternative to P&W; critique of apostolic-authority worship governance (new 2026-05-05) - [[Blended Worship]] — Webber-era convergence framing; integration of historic liturgy, hymnody, and contemporary song (new 2026-04-22) - [[Christian Nationalism]] — political-theological movement; overlaps with NAR Dominionism; seven-mountains theology; now carries a three-vantage critique layer (moderate-evangelical Holy Post + mainline Coons/Wired Word + discernment/ex-insider); book-length primary source still the goal (updated 2026-07-06) - [[Purity Culture]] — 1990s–2000s evangelical abstinence movement; worth-as-depletable-object commodification ("used gum"/"used car"/deflating balloon); documented religious-trauma and deconstruction trigger; two ex-insider sources (Mader + Kate Johnson) (new 2026-07-06) - [[Faith and Doubt]] — Partnership framing vs. NAR's doubt-as-threat framing - [[Fallible Prophecy]] — NAR doctrine that prophets can be wrong and remain prophets; critiqued against Deut 18:20–22 - [[Hillsongization]] — Gerardo Marti 2017 term for the export of Hillsong aesthetics and theology into non-Hillsong congregations - [[Holy Humor Sunday]] — Risus Paschalis, Bright Sunday, Second Sunday of Easter - [[Inclusive Language Hymnody]] — Mainline-progressive worship-music tradition; UCC New Century Hymnal - [[Liturgical Calendar]] — Christian year, Revised Common Lectionary, and tradition differences (including NAR's "prophetic calendar" replacement) - [[Praise and Worship Theology]] — Pentecostal/charismatic framework; Cornwall, Zschech; musical sacramentality - [[Progressive Christianity]] — Mainline-and-adjacent tradition with LGBTQ+ affirmation, liberation hermeneutics, and doubt-tolerant formation - [[Open and Affirming]] — UCC covenant designation for full LGBTQ+ inclusion (membership, leadership, ordination, marriage, sacrament); congregational form of [[Progressive Christianity]]'s inclusion commitment; Derek A. Terry's *We Shall Not Be Moved!* liturgy; queer-affirming hermeneutics (new 2026-06-28) - [[Resurrection as Rebellion]] — Paula Gooder's framing; political/ethical resurrection - [[Telos and Finishing Well]] — Greek *telos*; mainline frame for faithful endings and church closure as sanctification (new 2026-04-23) - [[Apostolic Authority]] — NAR claim of restored governmental apostolic office; Eph. 4:11 reading; harm analysis (unaccountable leadership, prophetic coercion, DARVO, doctrinal insulation); ecumenical context; UCC contrast (new 2026-05-01) - [[Five-Fold Ministry]] — Eph. 4:11 apostle/prophet/evangelist/pastor/teacher; NAR governance hierarchy; cessationist and mainline counter-readings; structural accountability gap; worship-theology connection (new 2026-05-02) - [[The Inclusive Bible]] — *The Inclusive Bible: The First Egalitarian Translation* (Priests for Equality, 2007); gender-expansive divine language, YHWH restored, "Human One" for Son of Man; used at St. John's UCC (new 2026-04-30) - [[Worship Music Vetting Projects]] — Cross-tradition catalog of CCLI-evaluation efforts (UMC, Calvin, NAR-critical) (new 2026-04-22) - [[Worship Song Vetting Rubric St Johns UCC]] — St. John's UCC draft rubric; 7 categories; 4-tier system; trauma-informed additions; Bryan Sirchio/CMP starter songs (new 2026-04-24) - [[Koinonia]] — *koinonia* (κοινωνία); Pauline theology of shared gospel partnership; Phil 1:5/2:1 as thematic brackets around the Christ hymn; material and relational dimensions (Phil 4:15–18); NAR counter-model; *eritheia* criterion (Phil 2:3); local embodiment at St. John's UCC (NETWork, food insecurity, Habitat) (new 2026-05-18) - [[The Passion Translation]] — TPT; single-translator Bible by Brian Simmons; functions as the NAR's in-house Scripture; divine-revelation claim as designed unfalsifiability; Mike Winger / Pivec critique; 2022 Bible Gateway delisting; worship-vetting flag (new 2026-06-09) - [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] — NAR strategic-level spiritual warfare (SLSW); C. Peter Wagner; territorial spirits and spiritual mapping; harm assessment; Walter Wink mainline contrast (powers as institutional spirituality); IHOPKC connection (new 2026-05-27; stub) - [[Theodicy]] — the justice of God in the face of evil and suffering; Epicurus trilemma; logical/evidential/pastoral variants; five major responses; NAR implicit theodicy (SLSW as theodicy); Caroline Saxton's lament-and-presence pneumatology; deconstruction entry point; four vault sources (new 2026-05-27) - [[NAR Fallacy Taxonomy]] — reusable 56-fallacy inventory across formal logic, relevance, presumption, ambiguity, manipulation, religious-specific, cognitive bias, and BITE-model categories; cross-referenced to Welton/Bethel corpus, WHO analysis corpus, IHOPKC, Hillsong, Trim Healthy Mama; academic tradition; pedagogical argument for hermeneutical genealogy (new 2026-05-20) - [[Musical Sacramentality]] — new 2026-05-05; see Concepts above - [[Word-and-Table Liturgy]] — new 2026-05-05; see Concepts above - [[Covenant Renewal Worship]] — new 2026-05-05; see Concepts above ## Sources - [[2026-08-st-johns-ucc-ten-commandments-series|2026 Aug–Sep St. John's UCC — Ten Commandments Series]] — Rev. [[Caroline Saxton]]'s four-part Decalogue series (Aug 16–Sep 6) with Matthew 22:34-40 as the weekly lens; **relationship precedes rule** (Exodus 19 before 20) and Jacobson's "not self-improvement, but neighbor improvement"; enfleshed's remixed commandments and Godly Play's heart arrangement; **idol is not icon** (icons deepen devotion, an idol replaces God); the third-commandment turn — "The theological and political threat posed by white [[christian-nationalism|Christian nationalism]] is directly tied to this commandment" and "Do not use God's name to do harm, period"; the neighbor table read against war, ICE detention deaths, and measles; an **unresolved** Exodus 20:5-6 theodicy preached honestly ("I will admit that I struggle"); the wiki's first pulpit application of the Christian-nationalism frame; Sep 6 recorded as scheduled-not-delivered; open transcription conflict Ukraine/Iran flagged; Gillette/Jacobson/enfleshed entity candidates (new 2026-09-04) - [[2026-08-09-st-johns-ucc-blessing-of-animals-sabbath-jubilee|2026-08-09 St. John's UCC — Blessing of the Animals and Sabbath Jubilee]] — Deuteronomy 15 *shemitah* paired with the prodigal son to build a **jubilee theology**, Lord's Prayer in its "debts" form; Blessing of the Animals doing structural work rather than pastoral decoration (Leviticus 25:1-7 widens sabbath release to land and creatures — creation care argued from sabbath economics, not stewardship sentiment); calendar-layering method (Hebrew date, Parashat Re'eh read the day before, RC commemorations, UN observances); companion to [[2015-05-24-laudato-si-francis]] (new 2026-09-04) - [[2026-08-ecclesiastes-comparative-translation-study|2026 Ecclesiastes 4–12 — Comparative Translation Study]] — Courtney's twelve-chapter Qohelet study, chapters 4–12 revised in-window; **seven translations side by side** including three Jewish (CJB, TLV, OJB) used to surface what Christian versions smooth over (OJB's retained *Bo're*/*bechurot*; the 4:17/5:1 Jewish-Christian versification seam); [[hermeneutical-genealogy|Hermeneutical Genealogy]] operationalized as a fixed template (Dominant Traditions / Suppressed Readings / Genealogical Surprises / Power Analysis); a Contemporary Voices panel with every entry tagged inference and each reader's method labeled — Levine's refusal of a supersessionist *Bo're*→Christ reading is a reusable guardrail, Gafney's "whose youth?" is the DEIB move; *zekhor* as covenantal reorientation, 12:7 as exact reversal of Genesis 3:19; six-phase-method concept page flagged (new 2026-09-04) - [[readwise-worship-industry-economics-cluster|Readwise — Worship Industry Economics Cluster (2026-08)]] — six sources answering **who decides what a congregation sings and what they're paid for it**; CCLI's origin (Dec 1984 Bible Temple Portland, the $3.1M Archdiocese suit, Rachinski's blanket license, $75/yr 1985 → 450,000+ songs) as a genuine fix that became a metering system, then a chart, then de facto A&R; three administrators (Capitol CMG/Essential/Integrity) near **80% of the Top 100**, Integrity's own VP putting 50–55% of revenue in church licensing and 97% of that via CCLI; the conglomerate argument (advance-and-recoupment turns coercive when the incentive to keep an artist unrecouped flips from absent to present); **credit share as annuity** — writing-camp splits handed out by the pastors advising the writers who depend on them, a financial-coercion mechanism inside the [[Apostolic Authority]] structure (one disguised source; mechanism alleged, splits checked); Keith Green and Rich Mullins as two documented **revenue-model dismantlings** (Mullins's cap-and-don't-tell-me design is the portable one); Baucham's "affective principle" coinage and the 1950s-vs-1970s traditionalism debunk — diagnosis sharper than its evidence; supplies a fourth vetting question upstream of theology, origin and money: **who is credited, and did any of them hold authority over the writer?** (new 2026-09-04) - [[readwise-branham-message-exit-cluster-2026-08|Readwise — Branham Message Exit-Testimony Cluster (2026-08)]] — eleven [[john-collins|John Collins]] episodes extending the wiki's existing six; **growth as campaign** (35 churches at [[William Branham]]'s 1965 death → ~250 by 1971; Six Day War timing, FGBMFI funding, a resurrected 1954 healing film, recruitment out of UPC/AoG/Apostolic congregations — *institutional non-condemnation is a recruitment asset*); the restoration chain → new concept [[restoration-narrative|Restoration Narrative]]; Shrode's audit of Liardon's *God's Generals* against court records and coroner's reports, turning on Liardon's line that personal problems "should be held separate from the call of God" — **"We didn't add a requirement for leadership. We traded one out."**; [[bob-scott|Bob Scott]] on the **corporate apostle** (GI Bill business education → 1980s consultant circuit → CEO governance; *diakonos* is a table waiter); the mechanism outside the movement — ECC's "spoken word" borrowing via Ern Baxter, Costa Rican **gradualism** and the *encuentro* (Adriana's teenage inference: the same people at every altar call), YWAM debt whiteboards produced by Values 13 and 16 rather than by bad actors; three checklist episodes (punished discernment; ordinary things weaponized so daily life needs the leader's mediation; tape home church, where the *inconsistency produced no friction*); ex-adherent advocacy throughout, mechanisms confident and genealogies provisional (new 2026-09-04) - [[2026-08-skillet-coopers-nar-church-abuse|2026-08 Skillet's John and Korey Cooper on NAR and Church Abuse]] — the wiki's strongest first-person source on **covering doctrine as lived**; thirty years inside, the apostle is Korey's brother-in-law and John's former best friend, her father an elder; told they "might not be safe" outside the covering, friends given prophetic word to cut them off; ~40% of the congregation gone, 100+ abuse claims, a firm the apostle himself hired finding a "longstanding pattern of abuse" and recommending permanent removal, met with silence; the apostle as **foundation and root** (blessing flows through him; Acts 2:42 read as being about him) and the leaked elders-only paper **demoting Paul** to protect a living apostle — the inverse of the usual continuity argument; "the only orthodox hermeneutic in a church is the apostolic hermeneutic" belongs verbatim in [[Apostolic Authority]]; a seven-step exit playbook overlapping the independently-assembled *Spiritual Grooming* list at four points; John Cooper publicly defended apostolic churches to Childers in 2021 and is now the case study; the father-in-law's entire reply to the apostle calling his daughter's claims demonic: **"Be careful, John."**; network unnamed in the source — do not supply one (new 2026-09-04) - [[readwise-hebrew-bible-scholarship-cluster-2026-08|Readwise — Hebrew Bible Scholarship Cluster (2026-08)]] — nine sources, six [[dan-mcclellan|McClellan]]; the load-bearing claim: **there is no devil in the Hebrew Bible** (*satan* a generic noun for accuser/adversary, 27 occurrences, many of them human; "devil" enters only via Greek *diabolos*) — which undercuts the territorial-demon architecture in [[spiritual-warfare-theology|Spiritual Warfare Theology]] and Wagner's strategic-level warfare, and pairs with [[divine-council|Divine Council]] as the alternative model; four method demonstrations (the nativity accounts' incompatible *internal logic*, not just discrepancies; Numbers 16 as composite with the sons-of-Korah psalms as the external constraint; Leviticus 25's explicit Israelite-vs-foreign contrast and *ish* as a term of art; Exodus 22:28-29 arguing that literalism does not exist and the tradition, not the text, is the authority); the racial-claims episode's philology (Hebrew "white"/"fair" terms denote shininess/ruddiness, not race) with its closing motive judgment marked as beyond the analysis; Nicaea as a **stability operation** — an already-organized diocesan network as "a system of intel dropped into his lap," the same shape as [[translocal-networking-local-isolation|Translocal Networking, Local Isolation]]; the Wes Huff item kept as the wiki's worked example of the reaction-to-a-reaction format problem; Hebrew Roots as a **foundation** rather than corruption problem — the standing question to put to every movement (new 2026-09-04) - [[readwise-christian-nationalism-current-events-2026-08|Readwise — Christian Nationalism Current Events (2026-08)]] — five August sources applying theology to events live; the mechanism worth keeping is **credibility-enhancing display** — Joel Webbon's "You starve. Glory be to God. You starve." signals in-group commitment by publicly discarding love of neighbor in the in-group's name, which explains why cruelty is stated rather than implied (add to [[NAR Fallacy Taxonomy]] as a mechanism, beside [[darvo|DARVO]] which explains the response to criticism); the clip's own premise concedes that the state, not the church, carries poverty relief; the Good Samaritan inverted; McClellan's steelman failing on Galatians 6:10, 1 Timothy 5 and 2 Thessalonians 3:10, with Isaiah 1 condemning the move; household-level formation as deliberate political strategy (Natalie Harp) flagged as a wiki gap; an "antichrist" essay that **rules out** the end-times and historical-model readings before arguing — the opposite of the [[eschatology|Eschatology]] pattern this wiki tracks; the Lake Ontario order landing on Haudenosaunee rather than Canadian history (Wendat/Huron origin; Seneca *Sganyatá·yo'*; 1794 Treaty of Canandaigua) as the DEIB lens doing real work; same-month counterpart to the pulpit application in [[2026-08-st-johns-ucc-ten-commandments-series]] (new 2026-09-04) - [[readwise-inclusion-and-decolonial-cluster-2026-08|Readwise — Inclusion and Decolonial Theology Cluster (2026-08)]] — six sources on who is inside the circle and who decides; Alex Wolf's three claims — **the incarnation as divine self-disabling**, disability as a spectrum anyone can join rather than a fixed minority, and **belonging rather than hospitality** (hospitality invites people into space built without them) — the last portable into every inclusion argument the wiki holds including [[open-and-affirming|Open and Affirming]], plus the ADA church exemption used rather than built past; **Christian supremacy** converged on independently by a Black ex-evangelical panel (it *produced* white supremacy via the Doctrine of Discovery, not the reverse) and by Taylor in [[2026-07-21-taylor-christian-supremacy-markers]] — two directions, one term, so the concept page should carry it; Cheryl Lindsay's UCC method for building a season around the Marks of Faithful and Vital Congregations (a congregation pausing all fundraising six months as "active rest"); Fuglesang's argument that **direct scriptural engagement beats name-calling**, matching what the exit testimonies say from the other side; and the end of the postwar "mere Christianity" consensus — young seekers choosing denominational particularity, which bears on why [[restoration-narrative|restoration narratives]] recruit well; disability-theology concept page and Randy Woodley entity flagged, not built (new 2026-09-04) - [[2026-05-23-decolonizing-great-commission-thomas|2026-05-23 Thomas — Decolonizing 'The Great Commission']] — Fr. Joash P. Thomas (substack, read 57%); decolonial / St. Thomas Christian. Argues "The Great Commission" is a colonial-era framing, not ancient doctrine — a subheading absent from the Greek, Matthew 28 addressed to the apostles. Missionary-as-colonial-agent (Carey, Taylor); Synod of Diamper (1599); transformation-vs-transaction. Critique-side companion to [[dominionism]] / [[seven-mountain-mandate|Seven Mountain Mandate]]. - [[2026-04-12 St Johns UCC]] — Holy Humor / Thomas Sunday, Rev. Caroline Saxton - [[2026-04-14 Fallible Prophecy NAR]] — YouTube interview critiquing NAR fallible-prophecy doctrine - [[2026-04-19 St Johns UCC Pauls Conversion]] — 3rd Sunday of Easter, Paul's Conversion; full sermon "Converted, Called, and Commissioned" - [[2026-04-21 Aniol — Stop Singing Hillsong, Bethel, Jesus Culture, and Elevation]] — Scott Aniol, G3 Ministries, 2022; Reformed-cessationist critique - [[2026-04-21 Modern Reformation — A Movement's Music]] — Modern Reformation essay, 2024; three-question worship-screening frame - [[2026-04-21 CFT — Inclusive Language Music and Hymns]] — Anne Linstatter, Christian Feminism Today; three approaches to inclusive-language hymnody - [[2026-04-21 CMP — What Is the Convergence Music Project]] — Progressive worship-music network - [[2026-04-21 CFT — The Singer and the Song Book Review]] — Reta Halteman Finger on Miriam Therese Winter autobiography - [[2026-04-21 Just and Generous Worship Music (podcast series) — ingest stub]] — Progressive worship-music podcast; eps 2 and 3 flagged for next cycle - [[2026-04-22 Blended Worship Cross-Traditional Highlights]] — NAD Ministerial, Reformed Worship, Biola, UCC MLA, UCC ONA Coalition, UMC Congregational Song, Calvin CCLI, Roelofs-on-workers (new 2026-04-22) - [[2026-04-23 Wired Word Finishing Well Church Closures]] — Weekly Wired Word curriculum; Sisters of Charity dissolution + mainline church decline; *telos* framing (new 2026-04-23) - [[2026-04-26 St Johns UCC Paul and Silas]] — 4th Sunday of Easter; NL442; Acts 16:16–34; spirituals tradition as hermeneutic; prophetic justice (Birmingham, Standing Rock); 57/65 sermon rubric (new 2026-04-27) - [[2026-04-24 Worship Music Vetting Compendium]] — 10-section St. John's UCC worship-music compendium; Hobbs, Ingalls, Bryan Sirchio, Brian Hehn, ecumenical CCLI project, manipulation anatomy, inclusive sources, vetting rubric (new 2026-04-24) - [[2026-05-03 St Johns UCC Paul at Athens]] — 5th Sunday of Easter; NL443; Acts 17:16–31 + John 14:15–21; natural theology, divine immanence, liberationist economic hermeneutic; score 48/65; sermon analysis complete 2026-05-07 (new 2026-05-03; updated 2026-05-07) - [[readwise-afro-christian-convention-yvonne-delk|Afro-Christian Convention — Yvonne Delk (Readwise Highlights)]] — Readwise partial ingest (2 highlights); Yvonne Delk; white ecclesiology critique; Afro-Christian worship as UCC gift; Black liberation theology (new 2026-05-08; partial — full book ingest priority) - [[2026-05-10 St Johns UCC Partnership in Gospel]] — NL444; Phil 1:1–18a + Luke 9:46–50; Sixth Sunday of Easter / Mother's Day; full sermon notes ingested 2026-05-11; koinonia, partnership vs. domination, unity not uniformity; 3 local partnerships (NETWork, food insecurity, Habitat); hermeneutical audit of Phil 1:15–18 and Phil 1:1 plural episcopate; rubric scoring pending recording (updated 2026-05-11) - [[readwise-field-notes-for-the-wilderness-bessey|Field Notes for the Wilderness (Sarah Bessey)]] — Sarah Bessey; deconstruction memoir; wilderness-as-grace, evolving faith, spiritual bypassing, Against→Toward movement, tikkun olam; 18 highlights (new 2026-05-10) - [[readwise-black-liturgies-riley|Black Liturgies (Cole Arthur Riley)]] — Cole Arthur Riley; Black liturgical prayers; liturgy-as-rest, ritual-as-mooring, non-contingent dignity; DEIB lens on worship; 4 highlights (new 2026-05-10) - [[readwise-shaping-of-the-ucc-gunnemann|The Shaping of the United Church of Christ (Louis H. Gunnemann)]] — Louis H. Gunnemann; UCC institutional history; founded 1957; "united and uniting" as identity + vocation; streams survive merger; two costs (neglected ecclesiology + ungrounded activism); covenant/called-community ecclesiology; constitutional provision limiting accountability (Loc 886); identity-surrender + "oneness, not diversity" contradiction vs. [[Open and Affirming]]; expanded 3→11→27 highlights (new 2026-05-10; expanded 2026-06-17, 2026-07-02) - [[2026-05-17 St Johns UCC Christ Hymn]] — NL442; Phil 2:1–13; Seventh Sunday of Easter / Pentecost Eve; prep stub from 6 Working Preacher snips; kenosis as counter-imperial choice; Christ hymn as pre-Pauline liturgical song; "have the same mind" as directed verb; Hymn Sing Sunday; Habitat Q&A after worship (new 2026-05-11) - [[2026-05-19 Bethel's Book Platformed a Wolf]] — YouTube exposé (~6 hrs); Jonathan Welton clergy sexual abuse at Welton Academy (2013–2018); Danny Silk's *Unpunishable* as coverup vehicle; 56-fallacy taxonomy (§X); publisher network map (§XVII: Destiny Image / Charisma House / ministry-imprint axis); Ben Armstrong anchor case study collapse (Feb 2026); tradition under critique: NAR/Bethel axis (new 2026-05-19; expanded 2026-05-20) - [[2026-05-24 St Johns UCC Pentecost]] — Day of Pentecost; dual-text pneumatology (John 20:19-23 + Acts 2:1-21); Johannine vs. Lukan Pentecost comparison; Joel 2 hermeneutics (egalitarian reading vs. NAR prophetic-hierarchy appropriation); Hymn 225 "On Pentecost They Gathered" (PASS) + Hymn 229 "Let Every Christian Pray" (PASS) + Dorsey/Schrader anthem "Precious Lord" (PASS); Kelly Latimore Pentecost icon; Shavuot/Pentecost convergence 2026; Illustrated Ministry liturgical texts; worship-theology connections to inclusive music selection standards (new 2026-05-23) - [[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]] — Pivec & Geivett, *A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement* (Baker Books); evangelical-cessationist critique; working definition of NAR; apostolic authority submission logic; accountability gap; soaking music as NAR worship practice; Passion Translation; Destiny Image publisher network; 369M global participants; Assemblies of God divergence; 5-criteria apostle test; new dead link: [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] (new 2026-05-24) - [[research-world-harvest-outreach-nar|The New Apostolic Reformation and World Harvest Outreach: A Comprehensive Analysis]] — Courtney's Nov 2025 research document; World Harvest Outreach (Chambersburg, PA NAR congregation); explicit "Apostolic community" self-identification; documented NAR organizational connections; trauma-informed methodology; PARTIAL INGEST — 60KB document; local-context pastoral significance for St. John's UCC (new 2026-05-24; full ingest pending) - [[2026-06-07 St John's UCC — Ruth: Loss and Loyalty]] — guest sermon, Rev. Peter Emig (Caroline Saxton at Keystone Conference); Ruth 1; *hesed*; purity→faithfulness shift; welcome-of-the-stranger; summer Ruth series (no NL designation); score 50/65; Habitat-thread correction (new 2026-06-09) - [[readwise-passion-translation-critique-cluster|Readwise — Passion Translation Critique Cluster]] — Readwise batch on [[The Passion Translation]]; Simmons primary clips + Mike Winger evangelical critique; built the TPT concept page, Brian Simmons and Mike Winger entities (new 2026-06-09) - [[readwise-pentecostal-nar-origins-critique-cluster|Readwise — Pentecostal / NAR Origins Critique Cluster]] — three polemical podcasts tracing Pentecostalism/NAR to Parham→Seymour→Dowie and a "secret church/special knowledge" doctrine; Azusa Street failed-prophecy record; source-caution flagged (new 2026-06-09) - [[readwise-monte-mader-christian-nationalism|Readwise — Inside Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]] — *Data Over Dogma* interview; ex-Christian-nationalist insider testimony (militancy, urgency, patriarchy, "mask off"); first primary source for the Christian Nationalism concept (new 2026-06-09) - [[2026-07-05-data-over-dogma-monte-mader-purity-culture|Inside Purity Culture and Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]] — second, later *Data Over Dogma* Mader episode (hosts McClellan + Beecher); purity culture as commodification ("used gum"/"used car") and consent-denial doctrine, the "wives submit" Sunday-school walkout, viral-platform origin and doxxing backlash, "let the Bible be messy" method; DARVO/minimization callout (father "forgives" her assailant); 2nd primary source for [[Christian Nationalism]], first for purity culture; built [[Monte Mader]] entity; source-caution (new 2026-07-05) - [[2026-07-05-unbelief-coons-faith-and-politics|Sen. Chris Coons on Christian Nationalism and Faith in Politics (Unbelief)]] — *Unbelief* podcast; Sen. Chris Coons (mainline) on why progressive faith ceded scriptural language to Christian nationalism; "the Bible is not a political document" + preference-for-the-poor (Isaiah 61 / Luke 4); whole-context vs. "harvested verses"; mainline ONA-as-lived-practice; Moral Majority/Falwell root; [[Pope Leo XIV]] emphasis-shift; 3rd primary source for [[Christian Nationalism]] and 2nd for [[Open and Affirming]]; built [[Chris Coons]] stub; source-caution (new 2026-07-05) - [[readwise-life-after-doom-mclaren|Life After Doom — Brian D. McLaren (Readwise)]] — Brian McLaren, *Life After Doom* (2023); doom as pre-traumatic stress, fourfold path, post-colonial hermeneutics (Bible kidnapped by colonizing frameworks), real horizon of biblical eschatology (end of dominating civilization), hope vs. optimism (Havel/Maathai), C-biases as NAR diagnostic; prerequisite source for [[Deconstruction]] concept page (new 2026-05-27) - [[Rededicate 250 and the Revival Rally Machine — WBHR Podcast Ep. 629]] — William Branham Historical Research podcast (John Collins + ex-IHOPKC Brantley Smith); reads the National Mall "Rededicate 250" event as a recurring "revival-as-political-rally" machine; Jezebel/Ahab branding technique (Branham→Ahn/Engle); Christian nationalism genealogy; built [[Lou Engle]], [[Cindy Jacobs]], [[Che Ahn]] entities; source-caution flagged (new 2026-06-11) - [[Dan McClellan Livestream Q&A (June 2026)]] — open Q&A; developing monotheism / divine council, Pauline pseudepigraphy, rapture-as-recent-and-American, method-over-apologetics; built [[Dan McClellan]] entity (new 2026-06-11) - [[Dan McClellan — Responding to "Feminism Has Satanic Roots"]] — rebuttal video; debunks witch-trial/midwife-abortion claim (Malleus Maleficarum + 20th-c. reclaiming); names bad-history-weaponized-for-authoritarianism; [[DARVO]] at narrative level (new 2026-06-11) - [[UCC Manual on Ministry (2018)]] — UCC ministerial authorization; covenantal polity, priesthood of all believers, Member-in-Discernment process, Fitness Review; mainline counter-model to apostolic appointment (contradiction callout vs. [[Apostolic Authority]]) (new 2026-06-11) - [[Bob Scott — The Guru Model Behind Modern Prophecy (Ep. 630)]] — structural theory of charismatic prophecy as single-mediator "guru" authority; media confers rank, competition escalates claims; mirror of [[Apostolic Authority]]; built [[Bob Scott]] entity (new 2026-06-11) - [[Dan McClellan — Sodom & Gomorrah Is Not About Homosexuality]] — Genesis 19 read in its own categories (inhospitality / dominance-assault), not the <200-year-old category of orientation; "act of power, not desire"; anachronism principle; DEIB clobber-passage reframe (new 2026-06-11) - [[The Hidden History Behind Calvary Chapel and the Vineyard — Cover-Up Culture]] — investigative lineage (Chuck Smith Sr./Jr., John Wimber, Lonnie Frisbee, Paul Cain); institution-protects-the-leader pattern; pre-NAR soil for [[Apostolic Authority]]; source-caution flagged; new dead-link stubs [[Lonnie Frisbee]], [[Paul Cain]], [[John Wimber]], [[Chuck Smith]] (new 2026-06-11) - [[2026-06-14-assemblies-of-god-1949-nar-latter-rain-youtube|The Assemblies of God Warned Us About the N.A.R. in 1949]] — YouTube discernment video; Assemblies of God 23rd General Council (1949) condemnation of the "New Order of Latter Rain" as the forerunner of the NAR; "condemnation reads like a checklist for today's NAR"; expulsion-not-extinction / migration-to-networks mechanic; AoG proper vs. Independent split; partially fills the [[Latter Rain]] open question for the 1949 statement; source-caution flagged (new 2026-06-14) - [[2026-04-12-st-johns-ucc-holy-humor-thomas-sunday|St. John's UCC — Holy Humor Sunday / Thomas Sunday (2026-04-12)]] — Holy Humor / Thomas Sunday (Second Sunday of Easter) at St. John’s UCC; earliest analyzed service in the sermon-source series (indexed 2026-07-19, clearing orphan) - [[2026-06-14-st-johns-ucc-ruth-gleaning-and-hope|St. John's UCC — Ruth: Gleaning and Hope (June 14, 2026)]] — Rev. Caroline Saxton; Ruth 2 + Deut 24:19-22 + Luke 6:36-38; week 2 of summer Ruth series; gleaning as binding economic justice ("a matter of economics"), immigration foregrounded (imago Dei welcome), gendered/anti-immigrant violence named, Ruth's agency via Karen González's *The God Who Sees*; baptism of Oscar Wolfe; intercultural communion (new 2026-06-14) - [[2026-06-15-bethel-platform-problem-jed-hartley-632|Bethel Church Finally Admits the Platform Problem — Jed Hartley (Podcast Ep. 632)]] — Jed Hartley podcast Ep. 632; insider/survivor critique of [[Bethel Church]] as an entertainment **platform** ("we're not platforming Jesus, we're platforming these individuals"); accountability moves outside-in ("I called them, they did not call me"); "impact over truth" as operating value; consequentialist override of discernment; single critic-side clip, source-caution flagged (new 2026-06-15) - [[2026-06-15-tamice-spencer-helms-better-logics|Discovering Better Logics in a Binary World — Dr. Tamice Spencer-Helms (TNE Podcasts)]] — Dr. Tamice Spencer-Helms (TNE podcast); progressive/liberation/womanist; norms exposed as arbitrary at the margins, whiteness as a logic "that depends on not being black," refusal over conquest, "white supremacy lives in your body," trust-vs-scarcity faith practice; feeds [[Progressive Christianity]] and [[Deconstruction]] (new 2026-06-15) - [[readwise-nerd-faith-kessler|Nerd Faith (Rachel Kessler)]] — Rachel Kessler, *Nerd Faith*; progressive/apophatic; certainty (not doubt) as the spiritual danger, God as wholly other/unknowable, faith beyond intellectual assent, "chaotic good" values-over-rules; two fundamentalisms mirror each other; feeds [[Faith and Doubt]]; 13 highlights (new 2026-06-17) - [[2026-06-18-leaving-the-message-apostles-prophets-spiritual-covering|The Origins of Apostles, Prophets, and Spiritual Covering]] — Leaving the Message YouTube; companion to the 1949 AoG source; three Latter Rain errors live in the NAR — present-day apostles/prophets hierarchy, confession to a human "spiritual covering" (mediator/coercion), tongues-as-missionary-equipment via [[Charles Fox Parham]]; opens a spiritual-covering concept-page question; source-caution (new 2026-06-18) - [[2026-06-17-mckinnon-fear-prediction-vs-prophecy-wbhr-634|Why Fear-Based Prediction Is Not Biblical Prophecy (WBHR Ep. 634)]] — William Branham Historical Research Ep. 634 (Collins + McKinnon); NT test for prophecy (1 Cor 14:3 edify/exhort/comfort; 1 Thess 5:20-21 test all) vs. fear-based self-referential prediction; *When Prophecy Fails* dynamics; Branham's 1933 visions / 1977 date / India crusade / LA-sinks failures; enriches [[Fallible Prophecy]]; opens [[William Branham]] entity question; source-caution (new 2026-06-17) - [[2026-06-17-pivec-does-satan-give-psychics-real-power|Does Satan Give Psychics Real Power? (Holly Pivec)]] — Holly Pivec interviews a Christian magician; cold reading vs. hot reading, statistical base rates, memory distortion, controlled-test failures; "concede the experience, contest the interpretation"; naturalistic alternative to demonic-power claims for ex-NAR prophecy; contradiction callout vs. Michaelsson/Anderson; source-caution (new 2026-06-17) - [[2026-06-21-wired-word-men-losing-friends|Wired Word 06/21/2026 — Research Reveals That Men Are Losing Friends]] — Wired Word Father's Day issue; male friendship decline (27% of men have 6+ close friends in 2021 vs. 55% in 1990); Lukianoff's "Pick Your Ten"; David & Jonathan / Prov 27 / John 15 / Acts 4; church-as-place-for-friendship; ties to [[Koinonia]] (new 2026-06-18) - [[2026-06-18-remnant-radio-reformers-spiritual-gifts|Did Protestant Reformers Believe in Spiritual Gifts? (The Remnant Radio)]] — The Remnant Radio (Joshua Lewis); continuationist historical-theology Q&A; Scottish Reformation gift accounts (Wishart, Knox, Welsh, Bruce) + Samuel Rutherford's four-part prophecy test (a Reformed precedent that mirrors [[Fallible Prophecy]]); 163-scholars/seminaries list counters the "no credentialed continuationists" claim; "CEO pastor model" named as the real harm vector (converges with the NAR-critique cluster); continuationism cuts across the Calvinist/Arminian divide (31% Reformed); contradiction callout — pro-gifts framing vs. the wiki's critique sources; ignoratio-elenchi flag (title names Luther/Calvin/Wesley, answer pivots to the Scots); source-caution (single 1775 hagiographic source) (new 2026-06-19) - [[Dan McClellan — Autism Is Not Caused by Sin]] — rebuttal of "autism/deafness/depression are caused by sin" preaching; John 9:3 / Exodus 4:11 / Isaiah 45:7 credit God (not sin) with disability; *bara*/*demut* philology vs. the "Genesis 2 = creation finished, humans made perfect" proof-text; autism reframed as neurodivergence, not defect; "conviction is a feeling, not knowledge"; first disability-theology source; contradiction callout (charismatic "sin = sickness" healing theology vs. critical reading); ties to [[Theodicy]], [[Religious Trauma]], [[Dan McClellan]] (new 2026-06-20) - [[2026-06-21-st-johns-ucc-ruth-daring-to-act|St John's UCC — Ruth: Daring to Act]] — week 3 of the summer Ruth series; Rev. Caroline Saxton; Ruth 3:1-18 (threshing floor) + Matthew 7:7-12; "Reclaiming My Time" womanist responsive reading (Washington-Leapheart); World Refugee Day / Juneteenth frame; "Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone)" vetted (Tomlin, no NAR-network flag); prep stub — sermon body pending recording (new 2026-06-21) - [[2026-06-22-data-over-dogma-moloch-abortion-mike-lee|Data Over Dogma — Moloch, Mormons, and Mike Lee]] — Data Over Dogma (McClellan + Beecher), two formats (YouTube + podcast); rebuts Mike Lee's "altar to Moloch" abortion meme — category objection, fetus-as-property in Exodus 21, "Moloch" as *molk* sacrifice-noun not deity, 1 Kings 11 Milcom→Molech corruption, Israel's-own-God child-sacrifice reversal, Falwell/Weyrich wedge-issue history; second segment on religious-boundary policing (Pentagon LDS-Christian spat, self-identification thesis, bounded institutional authority, Mark 9 inclusion, social-club power read — expanded 2026-06-25 with the standalone "Pentagon Decided Mormons Aren't Christian" clip); 2nd primary source for [[Christian Nationalism]]; source-caution on overt political framing + self-flagged contested readings (new 2026-06-23) - [[2026-06-20-leaving-the-message-potters-house-escape-ep636|Leaving the Message — Inside Potter's House: One Man's Escape (Ep. 636)]] — John Collins (WBHR) interviews ex-member Dennis Crosby on Potter's House / Christian Fellowship Ministries (Wayman Mitchell, ex-Foursquare ~1983); fivefold→onefold "our apostle" authority, rules-as-boundary, "commune of your mind," silenced questions; BITE-model exit; built [[Potter's House Christian Fellowship Ministries]]; source-caution (new 2026-06-21) - [[2026-06-20-leaving-the-message-intercessory-prayer-nar-control-ep637|Leaving the Message — From Intercessory Prayer to NAR Control (Ep. 637)]] — Desjardins ex-NAR insiders; Wagner's "ends justify the means," Brian Simmons's apostolic-center abuse, armor-bearer/impartation niche, manufactured trance/gaslighting, three-categories-of-leaders taxonomy, Cindy Jacobs's Reformation Prayer Network + "Divorcing Baal"; enriched [[brian-simmons|Brian Simmons]] + [[Cindy Jacobs]]; source-caution (new 2026-06-21) - [[2026-06-20-leaving-the-message-church-of-god-political-roots-revivalism|Leaving the Message — Hidden Political Roots of Modern Revivalism (Church of God Deep Dive)]] — Collins's "architecture over theology" history; A. J. Tomlinson's Church of God (Cleveland) as centralized-sacred-authority origin; Roy Davis (Klan)/Straton/Winrod links; proto–Seven Mountains; built [[Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee)]]; ties to [[Christian Nationalism]]; source-caution (new 2026-06-21) - [[2026-06-20-minor-prophets-is-the-passion-translation-finished|Minor Prophets — Is the Passion Translation Finished?]] — Minor Prophets follow-up; traceable TPT plagiarism (Younan→Roth→TPT paraklete "ends the curse"; du Toit Mirror Bible; Bauscher Hebrews 12); Aramaic-primacy being scrubbed; "Jenga tower of trust"; Hebrews 12 → Bethel "unpunishable" convergence; built [[Minor Prophets Podcast]] (new 2026-06-21) - [[2026-06-23-how-the-passion-translation-changed-preaching|How the Passion Translation Has Changed Preaching]] — preaching-side companion to the Minor Prophets audit; verbatim montage of Dutch Sheets / Damon Thompson / Jesse Duplantis / Kevin Zadai preaching the fabricated John 14 "ends the curse" footnote; believer-deification extension ("the other savior is actually you"); Galatians 3 / Trinitarian-roles rebuttal; credential laundering ("Dr. Simmons") (new 2026-06-24) - [[Sean Feucht — Motion to Dismiss the $250,000 Donor-Fraud Suit]] — Roys Report; worship leader's defense to a donor-fraud suit never denies misuse, argues donor lost standing on gift, ministry is a First-Amendment "association of churches," donor's motive is political harassment; clean DARVO + appeal-to-legality + reverse-victim + slippery-slope specimen; first source on [[Sean Feucht]] and on financial accountability as an NAR power practice; source-caution (motion-stage, one-sided) (new 2026-06-26) - [[Dan McClellan — Is the Most Famous Bible Translation Really All That Good?]] — McClellan's three-part case against the KJV (later manuscripts, archaic English, form-bound literalism); "just a revision of the Bishops' Bible"; prestige as a 19th-century "historical accident" (Lerer/Norton/Hamlin & Jones); recommends updated NRSV; companion to the [[The Passion Translation]] thread + the ESV gender-ideology candidate; flags a possible bible-translation-philosophy concept page; 5th [[Dan McClellan]] source (new 2026-06-26) - [[2026-06-28-st-johns-ucc-ruth-new-life-open-and-affirming|St John's UCC — Ruth: New Life / Open and Affirming Sunday]] — week 4 (final) of the summer Ruth series; Rev. Caroline Saxton; Ruth 4:1-22 + Jeremiah 17:5-8 + the Magnificat (Luke 1:46-55); resolution as redemption/belonging for the outsider; also Open and Affirming Sunday on the Stonewall anniversary, whole order of worship from Derek A. Terry's *We Shall Not Be Moved!*; built the [[Open and Affirming]] concept page; hymns all mainline/public-domain (no NAR-network flags); pre-service scaffold, sermon body pending recording (new 2026-06-28) - [[2026-06-27-data-over-dogma-america-reads-the-bible|Data Over Dogma — America (Almost Never) Reads the Bible]] — Data Over Dogma (McClellan + Beecher); Segment 1 reads the Museum of the Bible "America Reads the Bible" marathon as Christian-nationalist theater (Trump's edited 2 Chronicles 7 NKJV reading; Intercessors for America given the Sermon on the Mount; 2 Chron 7:14's repentance condition unmet); Segment 2 argues the Bible never condemns suicide (Saul/1 Sam 31, Samson) — "sin/hell" framing is a post-biblical Augustine/Aquinas import with pastoral harm; 6th [[Dan McClellan]] source; 3rd primary source for [[Christian Nationalism]]; source-caution on political framing (new 2026-06-28) - [[2026-06-27-masculinism-doug-wilson-fresh-air|Fresh Air — Masculinism Goes Mainstream (Doug Wilson's patriarchal political theology)]] — NPR *Fresh Air* (Terry Gross + Helen Lewis) on "masculinism"; mostly secular, filed for the Douglas Wilson strand: covenant-household theology underwriting a religious case to repeal women's suffrage ("war on the family… started at Seneca Falls"), white-replacement natalism, Trump as "ultimate patriarch"; extends [[Christian Nationalism]]/[[Dominionism]] to the Reformed-theonomy side; 2nd Doug Wilson data point (after the 06-22 Pentagon note) → flags a Douglas Wilson entity for a directed pass; source-caution (secular outlet, critic-mediated) (new 2026-06-28) - [[2026-06-28-pivec-nar-anxiety-biblical-counselor|Holly Pivec — Is NAR Theology Fueling Your Anxiety? (EP 35)]] — [[Holly Pivec]] interviews a biblical counselor (Mark, *Reminded*) on how NAR "name it and claim it" / outcome-control theology fuels anxiety and depression; sharpest hook is the duty-vs-outcome contrast ("Duty is ours, the results are God's") against word-of-faith control logic; coins "generalized extreme condemnation syndrome" (GECS); contradiction flag — the biblical-counseling "anxiety = unbelief/sin" model carries its own documented pastoral harm; ties to [[Religious Trauma]], [[Spiritual Abuse]], [[Deconstruction]], and [[Dan McClellan — Autism Is Not Caused by Sin]]; 3rd [[Holly Pivec]] source; source-caution (new 2026-06-28) - [[2026-06-29-bethel-jed-hartley-damage-control-644|Bethel, Victims, and Charismatic Damage Control — Jed Hartley (WBHR Ep. 644)]] — William Branham Historical Research Ep. 644 (John Collins + Jed Hartley); reads a **deleted** clip of Bethel Music's Jen Johnson responding to abuse allegations (Ben Armstrong, [[Shawn Bolz]], Bob Hartley) as a charismatic damage-control playbook; "you only heard one side of the story" + identifying-with-the-accused as [[DARVO]]; "the edit becomes the story" (Branham "blank spots on the tape" analogy); [[IHOPKC]]/[[Mike Bickle]] in-house-then-independent template; [[Five-Fold Ministry]] pyramid as structural root; companion to [[2026-06-15-bethel-platform-problem-jed-hartley-632|Bethel Church Finally Admits the Platform Problem — Jed Hartley (Podcast Ep. 632)]]; resolves the Jed Hartley identity (son of Bob Hartley) → Jed Hartley + John Collins entity thresholds now met, held for directed pass; source-caution (new 2026-06-29) - [[2026-06-29-data-over-dogma-myth-of-12-tribes|Data Over Dogma — The Myth of the 12 Tribes of Israel]] — Data Over Dogma ([[Dan McClellan]] + Beecher); the "twelve tribes of Israel" as a late literary/ideological construct, not a stable historical roster; the "hydraulic" count (omit Levi, split Joseph → still twelve); Judges 5 / Song of Deborah preserves ~ten different groups; confederation theory; "most likely there was never a United Kingdom"; membership becomes ideological (Judahite conformity vs. the "dirty Samaritans") in the Second Temple period; anchors Staples (2021) + Tobolowski (2022); 7th [[Dan McClellan]] source; flags an "Israel as constructed identity" concept candidate; source-caution (provisional reconstruction) (new 2026-06-29) - [[2026-06-29-minor-prophets-pastors-quoting-word-of-god|Minor Prophets — 'And Pastors Are Quoting It as The Word of God' (TPT)]] — [[Minor Prophets Podcast]] (with David Fish); TPT as Brian Simmons's invented paraphrase quoted from pulpits as "the word of God"; cleanest doctrinal-insertion specimen yet — Psalm 81:10's manufactured "decree" (Word-of-Faith "decree and declare") chanted at Rod Parsley's church / quoted on Daystar with no attribution; "the word decree is never once used in the Bible"; documents the fake "theological review team" (Wadholm "simply to consult"; Keener/Strauss/Bird repudiate) and Candace Simmons as hidden uncredentialed editor; 3rd TPT source after [[2026-06-20-minor-prophets-is-the-passion-translation-finished|Minor Prophets — Is the Passion Translation Finished?]] + [[2026-06-23-how-the-passion-translation-changed-preaching|How the Passion Translation Has Changed Preaching]]; source-caution (polemical, in-house discernment) (new 2026-06-29) - [[2026-07-01-chapters-and-verses-versification-history|Chapters and Verses Are Reading the Bible for You (Data Over Dogma)]] — Data Over Dogma ([[Dan McClellan]] + Dan Beecher); history of how the Bible got its chapter/verse divisions — none original, all added by hand over centuries. *Scriptio continua* → Masoretic sense-units (*petuchah*/*setumah*, *atnach*) → Langton's Vulgate chapters (1200s) → 15th-c. verse numbers → Estienne's 1551 Greek NT versification → Geneva Bible (1560). Hermeneutical payoff: boundaries mislead (Eph 5:21–22 verb split); KJV per-verse layout served slow public reading. Source flags its own "92%" and "100 CE" figures as off-the-cuff (Leningrad Codex is ~1008–1010 CE); 8th [[Dan McClellan]] source; hermeneutics/versification concept candidate (new 2026-07-01) - [[2026-07-02-mcclellan-image-of-god-divine-council|Dan McClellan — What Does It Mean to Be Created \"In God's Image\"?]] — [[Dan McClellan]] critique of a devotional video on the *imago Dei*; image = representation/manifested presence (*tselem*/*demut* → outward form → functioning divine image), Genesis 1 democratizing ANE royal ideology so all humanity is God's representative "on earth"; Genesis 1:26 plural "let us make" = the divine council (*bene elohim*), **not** the Trinity (mid-to-late 2nd-c. CE doctrine) → contradiction callout; the "flesh is inherently sinful" reading tagged middle-Platonic/Gnostic and tied to the ~170 CE development of *creatio ex nihilo*; 9th [[Dan McClellan]] source; flags "divine council" + "imago Dei" concept candidates; source-caution (contemptuous tone; "uniformly anthropomorphic" is a scholarly position) (new 2026-07-02) - [[2026-07-02-wired-word-250th-civil-religion|The Wired Word — United States Turns 250 and Half of Churches Celebrate]] — The Wired Word for July 5, 2026 (mainline adult study); Lifeway survey (50/47/3 on marking the US 250th) as entry to a lesson on patriotism-in-worship and civil religion; names the risk in its own data (30% say love of country rivals love of God); "greatness alongside failure" (the excised Jefferson slavery clause; "Lift Every Voice and Sing"); four-passage spine (Deut 6:5 / Matt 22:21 / John 18:36 / Rom 13:1); a *pro-social civil-religion* counter-specimen to [[Christian Nationalism]] and the [[2026-06-27-data-over-dogma-america-reads-the-bible|Data Over Dogma — America (Almost Never) Reads the Bible]] marathon; prep resource (not a dated St. John's service); flags a "civil religion" concept candidate (new 2026-07-02) - [[2026-07-05-st-johns-ucc-esther-moment-like-this|St. John's UCC — Esther: A Moment Like This]] — Sixth Sunday after Pentecost at St. John's UCC; Rev. Caroline Saxton on Esther 4:1–17 + Luke 9:23–27; providence-without-spectacle (God unnamed but present), communal courage (three days of fasting before Esther risks the king), "comfort or courage, not both," position-for-purpose ("for such a time as this"), action-in-faith-before-understanding; "Lift Every Voice and Sing" programmed on July-5 weekend as a counter to triumphalist civil religion; updated [[Caroline Saxton]] (new 2026-07-06) - [[2026-07-05-unbelief-pastor-predator-deconstruction|Unbelief — When the Pastor Was the Predator (Kate Johnson)]] — *Unbelief* podcast; Kate Johnson (PCA pastor's-daughter deconstruction testimony); father a pastor arrested for CSAM when she was 9; church reframed the abuse as an "addiction" and recentered the offender ([[DARVO]]/spiritual-bypass forced forgiveness); purity-culture balloon metaphor compounded a later assault into shame; somatic/lament healing over reconciliation-through-forgiveness; anchors the new [[Purity Culture]] page; ties to [[Deconstruction]], [[Spiritual Abuse]], [[Religious Trauma]]; Kate Johnson logged as entity candidate; source-caution (new 2026-07-06) - [[2026-07-05-holy-post-725-americas-story-gupta-paul|Holy Post 725 — America's Story + Nijay Gupta on Paul]] — *Holy Post* 725; two segments. (1) moderate-evangelical critique of Christian nationalism: White House UFC "cage match" as pre-Christian/pagan display, "pagan masculinity"/manosphere diagnosis, the *Atlantic* "lost shared story," Pew 7%/9% extremes. (2) NT scholar Nijay Gupta on *Paul for the World*: restoration eschatology (Romans 8, "invasion" not rapture), Bonhoeffer's "holy worldliness" + prosperity-gospel critique, embodied/"upgraded" resurrection; feeds [[Christian Nationalism]] + [[Eschatology]]; Gupta/Schiess entity candidates; source-caution (new 2026-07-06) - [[2026-07-05-holy-post-727-mckenzie-sexual-revolution-250|Holy Post 727 — Robert Tracy McKenzie on America at 250]] — *Holy Post* 727; historian Robert Tracy McKenzie on America at 250; eyewitness to the National Mall "Rededicate 250" rally (Liberty U choir, cross with founders' images, "if my people…" shirts) as faith-nation conflation; founders avoided sectarian public religion; historical ignorance feeds the myth; "admirable ideals we fall short of" as the only unifying story; patriotism-as-gratitude-not-supremacy; third America-250 source, feeds [[Christian Nationalism]]; McKenzie entity candidate; captured highlights cover the 250 segment only; source-caution (new 2026-07-06) - [[2026-07-09-leaving-the-message-azusa-parhamite-roots-ep650|Azusa History Overturned: The Parhamite Roots — Leaving the Message Ep. 650]] — *Leaving the Message* / WBHR Ep. 650 (John Collins); argues NAR is rebranded "Parhamism" — the "Apostolic Faith" of [[Charles Fox Parham]] renamed; genealogy Dowie→Parham→Seymour→Branham→Latter Rain→NAR; primary-document core (*The Apostolic Faith*, Vol. 1 No. 1, LA 1906); Parham's 1907 arrest read as the reason the public face was swapped to Seymour ("coverup culture"); xenoglossy→unintelligible-tongues shift; enriched [[Charles Fox Parham]] + [[Pentecostalism]]; source-caution (single polemical podcast, one 1906 issue) (new 2026-07-10) - [[2026-07-09-remnant-radio-bethel-point-of-no-return|Is Bethel Church Past the Point of No Return? — The Remnant Radio]] — The Remnant Radio (Joshua Lewis); **continuationist-insider** decade timeline of [[Bethel Church]] scandals as a single fruit-inspection case (grave-soaking, "little blue genie," Bill Johnson Christology, *Physics of Heaven*, Bob Jones, Copeland, Shawn Bolz data-mining); distinct legal angle (California Silence No More Act) + biblical case (Eph 5 / 2 Cor 4 / 1 Tim 5 / Ezek 34); verdict "mark and avoid"; corroborates the 07-07 layoffs/NDA + David Fish TPT-plagiarism material; sibling to [[2026-07-07-bethel-layoffs-ndas-tpt-censorship|Bethel Layoffs, Non-Disparagement Agreements, and TPT Censorship — Wake Up and Win Podcast]]; source-caution (new 2026-07-10) - [[2026-07-09-wired-word-empire-state-boldness-risk|Wired Word — Couple Climbs Empire State Building (Week of July 12, 2026)]] — The Wired Word for the week of July 12, 2026 (mainline adult study); Empire State Building rooftopper stunt as a hook for a study on holy boldness vs. timidity; four-passage spine (Habakkuk 2 "write the vision" / Peter on the water / the talents / Paul & Silas at Philippi); "too timid… even as we avoid illegal acts"; Hauerwas "adventure over safety"; civil-disobedience question; recurring Wired Word thread; no theological red flags; source-caution (curriculum framing; self-flagged attribution/marriage uncertainties) (new 2026-07-10) - [[2026-07-09-tim-whitaker-dissent-prophetic-tradition|Discouraged by the State America Is In? — Tim Whitaker]] — Tim Whitaker (*The New Evangelicals*); a **constructive** counter to Christian nationalism — dissent as the most authentically Christian act; anti-imperial prophetic tradition (Amos/Isaiah/Micah/Jesus) traced through Ida B. Wells, Thurgood Marshall, MLK, each acting *because of* their faith; "faith of love and liberation" vs. "faith of power and domination"; names the church-authority formation that trains dissent-as-disloyalty; 4th vantage on [[Christian Nationalism]]; Tim Whitaker / The New Evangelicals entity candidates; source-caution (sermon, not historiography) (new 2026-07-10) - [[2026-07-10-counterfeit-kingdom-pivec-geivett|Counterfeit Kingdom — Holly Pivec & R. Douglas Geivett]] — Holly Pivec & R. Douglas Geivett, *Counterfeit Kingdom* (B&H, 2022); the flagship NAR-critique book, previously cited in passing but never given a source page. Supplies the wiki's affirmative prophecy-testing rubric (Orthodoxy / Lifestyle / Fulfillment tests; "evidence first, then belief"), the "activation resembles New Age awakening" charge against [[Bethel Church]]/[[Bill Johnson]], and the "want it both ways" double standard behind NAR prophetic unaccountability (COVID as the worked Fulfillment-Test failure); anchors the [[Holly Pivec]] entity; **expanded 2026-07-16** with the governance cluster from the re-synced highlight set (18 highlights) — apostolic authority as a governing office, the coercive prophetic-direction "Dean" testimony, blessings-as-bait recruitment, the Ephesians 4:11 "no offices, only elders and deacons" rebuttal, and "alignment = code for submission"; now feeds [[Apostolic Authority]] + [[Five-Fold Ministry]] + [[Spiritual Abuse]]; source-caution (cessationist-leaning; Dean account second-hand) (new 2026-07-11, expanded 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-10-uchimura-prophetic-nationalism|Nationalism Can Be Prophetic — Uchimura Kanzō (Kazusa Okaya)]] — Kazusa Okaya (*Christianity Today*) on the Japanese evangelist Uchimura Kanzō (1861–1930) as a model of "prophetic nationalism" (Yagyu Kunichika's term); a pre-WWII, non-Western vantage on [[Christian Nationalism]] — resisting the emperor-cult from inside patriotism ("I love two Js: Jesus and Japan"); the 1891 Rescript bow, Amos-grounded recantation of the Sino-Japanese War, Danish reforestation counter-model, and the Mukyokai "non-church" movement; distinct contribution names the *progressive* mirror-idolatry (critique-as-contempt); 5th vantage; source-caution (CT op-ed; secondary biographies) (new 2026-07-11) - [[2026-05-24-unbelief-evangelical-code-words-steele|Evangelical Code Words — Jeremy Steele (Unbelief podcast)]] — Jeremy Steele (*Unbelief* podcast, May 2026) on evangelical "code words" — how "spiritual warfare," "rebuke," "one nation under God," "rededication," "biblical values," and "purity" carry political/theological systems beneath a spiritual surface, learned in childhood via emotional habituation; the Peretti/*This Present Darkness* + armor-of-God formation origin; supplies the rhetorical-mechanism layer under [[Christian Nationalism]] and the congregational-rhetoric layer under [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]]; grounds the vault permanent note [[Evangelical Code Words Package Political Systems as Spiritual Wisdom]]; source-caution (solo post-evangelical commentary) (new 2026-07-11) - [[2026-07-12-data-over-dogma-wife-sister-deception|Data Over Dogma — When God Told Abraham to Lie (the wife-sister doublets)]] — *Data Over Dogma* ([[Dan McClellan]] + Dan Beecher), a re-shared segment ("When God Told Abraham to Lie") on the three Genesis "wife-sister" stories (Gen 12 / 20 / 26) as one popular tale kept in three tellings; the tidiest single-source case of the source-critical/documentary reading in the McClellan corpus — editors "kept it all," the story as a wealth-etiology, Sarah's erased agency, the theodicy of God punishing an unknowing foreign king, the half-sister patch (Gen 20:12), the Elohim-throughout / Tetragrammaton-only-in-v18 seam in Genesis 20, the YHWH-theophoric absence from all Genesis names (developing-monotheism), and the Philistine anachronism (Sea Peoples, 12th c. BCE); 9th [[Dan McClellan]] source; flags source-criticism + feminist-hermeneutics concept candidates + a prosperity-gospel data point; source-caution (casual podcast segment, un-footnoted) (new 2026-07-12) - [[2026-07-14-pivec-nar-distraction-false-gospel|Holly Pivec — Are Your Church's Teachings Distracting You From Jesus?]] — [[Holly Pivec]] + the *Reminded* biblical counselor (2nd episode with this guest); NAR as **attention capture** rather than doctrinal error alone — rebuking hurricanes, declarations worded "just right," anointing oil in the ground, buried communion elements — an unfalsifiable task list whose failures carry "no consequences," read against Martha in Luke 10 ("distracted. From what? Jesus"); the control/entrust distinction as the mental-health hinge; the Eden charge ("you can be like God" via secret knowledge + magical power); Pivec's crispest statement of the dominion move — the cross granted, then called an *incomplete* gospel; feeds [[Dominionism]] + [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] + [[Fallible Prophecy]]; source-caution (biblical-counseling frame; speaker attribution inferred) (new 2026-07-14) - [[2026-07-14-mcclellan-jesus-in-the-old-testament|Dan McClellan — \"Jesus in the Old Testament Is Beyond Dispute\]] — [[Dan McClellan]] stitch-reply; the wiki's first dedicated **typology / messianic-prophecy** source; retrojection thesis (nobody read Jesus into the Hebrew Bible until after his death; Matthew retold Mark's stories to produce the "fulfillments"); Genesis 3:15 as snake etiology not protoevangelium; the 351-prophecies list; circular presupposition (inspiration/inerrancy/univocality/historicity); 2 Cor 3 veil as tautology; Psalm 22 + Isaiah 7:14 as mistranslations; Isaiah 53's servant doesn't die and *is* Israel; "wrong spirit" framing as social-identity policing; flags **messianic-prophecy/typology** + **supersessionism** concept candidates; source-caution (polemical, uncited, ad hominem) (new 2026-07-14) - [[2026-07-14-mcclellan-women-pastors-heresy|Dan McClellan — \"Women Pastors Always Preach Heresy?\]] — [[Dan McClellan]] stitch-reply; "everyone ignores scripture because scripture is not univocal"; no passage bars women from the pastorate (the office occurs once, in passing, Eph 4, no qualifications, probably not Pauline); authentic Paul names a woman apostle (Romans 16 — Junia, unnamed in the video); 1 Cor 14 silence text an interpolation contradicting 1 Cor 11; 1 Tim 2:12 from the pseudepigraphic Pastorals → complementarians prioritize forgeries over authentic letters; "heresy just means an idea I don't like"; misogyny as a *credibility enhancing display*; grounds [[United Church of Christ]] practice in the critical case; advances **pseudepigraphy** (now at threshold) + **feminist hermeneutics** candidates; source-caution (contemptuous register; positions asserted, Junia unnamed) (new 2026-07-14) - [[2026-07-16-bill-johnson-defends-passion-translation|Bill Johnson Defends The Passion Translation (Rediscover Bethel)]] — **the wiki's first [[Bill Johnson]] primary source**; a Bethel-produced "Rediscover Bethel" interview (published 2021-09-21) answering "Is the Passion Translation heresy?"; his stated position is narrower than critics allow (teaches/writes only from NASB/NKJV "because they're more word-for-word," reads TPT "for passion, for inspiration," "I don't use it as a proof text," concedes "every Bible has an agenda"); **confirms the two-tier text practice in his own voice** — previously held on inference from a Permanent Note; moves [[The Passion Translation]]'s **[[DARVO]] entry from *anticipated* to *documented*** (deny/attack via "critical spirit"; attack the academy — "they may be scholars, but they don't have the relationship"; reverse-victim — critics as educated elitists vs. the "brand new believer"; closes on the Pharisee frame); yields the **selective epistemology** finding (honors scholarship where it produced his teaching texts, dismisses it where it critiques his devotional one); his best argument (the single-translator precedent — Phillips/Living/Message) given a fair hearing; source-caution (in-house media, friendly host, predates the 2022 platform removals and the 2026 plagiarism findings, misattributes the "burnt" quote to the NKJV) (new 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-16-bethel-alumni-calls-out-passion-translation|Why This Bethel Alumni Is Calling Out the Passion Translation]] — BSSM graduate Dusty May Taylor (2012–2015) on the *Pastor and Wife* podcast; the wiki's **first TPT reception testimony from inside Bethel**; TPT arrived as a **restoration** promise against "legalistic, partisan translators" ("this was the vibe"); the **epistemic-privilege inversion** that answers Johnson directly ("you have to be educated to know that. All of us who were not… seminary trained… had no idea until people like [[Minor Prophets Podcast]] started digging into it"); new textual specimen — the **glory reversal** ("everyone was giving Jesus glory" → "he gave glory to everyone"), met by "Oh, you're so legalistic"; **independently corroborates** the Candace Simmons undisclosed-editor problem ("*better*" is an editorial standard, not a translational one) and the [[2026-07-07-bethel-layoffs-ndas-tpt-censorship|Bethel Layoffs, Non-Disparagement Agreements, and TPT Censorship — Wake Up and Win Podcast]] suppression pattern (official BSSM alumni group: "can we discuss Passion Translation?" — **post rejected**; group once shut down over "accountability and correction"; bookstore pull reversed in two days); Lecrae-adjacent [[Deconstruction]] cost without total collapse; source-caution (one recollection a decade on, friendly venue, no Bethel response, "fraud" is her word, motive narrative self-labeled speculation) (new 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-16-remnant-radio-continuationists-cessationists|The Remnant Radio — Why Continuationists and Cessationists Keep Talking Past Each Other]] — **4th Remnant Radio source** (Joshua Lewis + Michael Miller); structural rather than doctrinal value — **four mechanisms** by which good-faith opponents misfire: theological genealogy (Wesleyan-Holiness/Arminian vs. Reformed/Calvinist roots), vocabulary mismatch for one phenomenon ("God told me" vs. "providence in hindsight"), suspicion of motive inherited from the **1904 Azusa Street** class/education divide, and judging the other camp by its worst rather than its best; occasioned by Lewis's own misdefinition of cessationism (the narrow claim is that *apostolic sign gifts* ceased, not all gifts) corrected by Justin Peters; supplies the continuationist **in-house boundary** on revelation — "those who do, we don't call them charismatics, we call them cult leaders"; **independently corroborates the Pharisee reflex** [[Bill Johnson]] performs the same day; third line on **Destiny Image** as an NAR-adjacent publishing structure (same Troy Brewer/time-code book as [[2026-07-14-remnant-radio-cracking-the-time-code|The Remnant Radio — Exposing \"Cracking the Time Code\" (Candice Smithyman)]]); source-caution (two continuationists representing cessationism secondhand; the mediating both/and is a position, not neutral ground; ASR renders "Arminian" as "Armenian") (new 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-16-rise-of-christian-record-labels|The Rise of Christian Record Labels (CCM History, Part 3)]] — Jonathan Allen Wright's CCM industry history (**part 3**; parts 1–2 not ingested); the **industrial pre-history** the worship-standards cluster lacked; Word Records (1951, from a fictional Jesus-vs-Satan football play-by-play), Manna/Myrrh (Billy Ray Hearn, 1972), ABC's minority stake (1974), Sparrow (1976), *CCM Magazine* (1978) **naming the genre** — the precondition for [[Hillsongization]] (no standardized worship product without a name for the product); the **bookstore as unaccountable gatekeeper** ("whoever controls that gate controls the art") — doctrinal filtering outsourced to retail buyers, the structural argument for congregation-level vetting; thesis: ~1976 "stops being a small ministry and starts being a business with a ministry attached"; **the video is sponsored by [[CCLI Reporting and Royalty Flow|CCLI]]** — the ad read sits immediately before the gatekeeping line, illustrating the thesis better than any example Wright chose; source-caution (popular history, no citations, declension narrative, founder's name garbled four ways — he is **Jarrell McCracken**) (new 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-16-off-code-lecrae-piper-confession|Off Code — Reacting to Lecrae's John Piper Confession]] — Monique Duson & Kevin Briggins (*Off Code*) reacting to Lecrae on John Piper; clean **false-dichotomy** specimen ("we're not going to change the hood with a reading program") — gospel and material aid framed as rivals for one slot; **[[DARVO]] reverse-victim applied to a deconstruction narrative** rather than to abuse ("they're not the ones who need to be looking in the mirror. **He does**… He needs to be moving back to where they are"); Lecrae's own **forgiveness/trust distinction** quoted against the frame ("I love him. I forgive him. **I don't trust him**") — a durable contribution to [[Faith and Doubt]], arriving via a source arguing against him; the hosts read that distinction as a failure to forgive, the conflation the wiki tracks in [[Spiritual Abuse]]; **DEIB note — do not flatten**: two Black commentators arguing a third Black Christian owes a return to predominantly white institutions; source-caution (reaction video, Lecrae absent, advocacy outlet, Duson is *weeks* into Piper's work by her own admission, **no primary Lecrae source in the wiki**) (new 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-16-wired-word-religion-health-report|The Wired Word — Religious People Live Longer and Better, Says Report (7/19/2026)]] — **5th Wired Word source**; the 7/19/2026 adult Sunday-school lesson on a Wheatley Institute (BYU)/Duke report synthesizing 1,069 studies (7:1 physical / 10:1 mental positive-to-negative; "that kind of ratio is almost never seen in the social sciences"); scriptures Gen 1:29, Mark 14:22, 1 Tim 4:7-8, Heb 10:24-25 → [[Koinonia]] ("gathering is an essential part of the life of the church"); weakness is **omission, not fabrication** — no correlation/causation distinction anywhere, and the one harm caveat (measles outbreaks; "religion should not preclude competent medical and mental health professionals") appears once and is never returned to; **new wiki observation — the attendance-as-health-variable confound**: the lesson's own metric (weekly-or-more attendance + high commitment) is the exact variable that predicts *harm* in a coercive community, linking the worship/community cluster to [[Spiritual Abuse]] from an unexpected direction; source-caution (devotional curriculum not a research document; everything secondhand via *Religion Unplugged*/*Deseret News*; the "seven years longer" claim untraceable from the note; BYU institutional interest named neutrally) (new 2026-07-16) - [[2026-07-14-remnant-radio-cracking-the-time-code|The Remnant Radio — Exposing \"Cracking the Time Code\" (Candice Smithyman)]] — The Remnant Radio (Joshua Lewis) reviewing *Cracking the Time Code* (Candice Smithyman, **Destiny Image**, 2025); the **dedicated prosperity-gospel/word-of-faith source** the 07-12 cycle pre-registered as the trigger for a standalone concept page; two named patterns of language abuse (outright invention ~18x vs. correct word + smuggled theology) with four checkable cases (*regel*=foot, *yada*=know not "I do," *halak* vs. Noah, *avad* in Gen 2:15 *before* the fall); *anablepo* → Christological heresy (Jesus spiritually degraded by looking at poor people); *aion*/*chronos* inflated into a multiverse; word-of-faith core (faith-as-income from Romans 4, perception "renders blessings powerless," death-as-optional via Enoch); carefully qualified **gnostic-adjacent** anthropology ("earth suit"); "you have no beginning and no end" collapsing the Creator/creature distinction; **continuationist-insider** vantage; 3rd Remnant Radio source; corroborates the Destiny Image network already named in [[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]]; source-caution (one-sided review; claims are Lewis's characterizations) (new 2026-07-14) - [[2026-07-17-mcclellan-let-us-make-man-divine-council|Dan McClellan — Let US Make Man in OUR Image?!?]] — [[Dan McClellan]] video, the **dedicated** treatment of Genesis 1:26's "us" (the 07-02 imago-Dei source handled it as one sub-point); rules out plural-of-majesty, *Elohim*'s grammar (singular *vayyomer Elohim* + first-person-plural cohortative), and the Trinity (a mid/late-2nd-c. CE doctrine, ~700 yrs after the text) before arguing the **divine council** (Psalm 82; Isaiah 6:8; Jeremiah 23:18; Genesis 3, 6, 11); Ugaritic El/Athirat/70-sons → 70 nations → 70 angelic princes; the monotheizing pivot (announced plurally in 1:26, executed with singular verbs in 1:27); flags the **contested** Deut 32:8–9 "second-tier Yahweh" reading (Heiser vs. Mark S. Smith) as his judgment not consensus; **second focused divine-council source → pushes `concepts/divine-council.md` over threshold**; source-caution (short explainer, gestures at scholarship uncited, captions garble the Hebrew) (new 2026-07-18) - [[2026-07-13-data-over-dogma-lean-not-proverbs-3-5|Data Over Dogma — Lean Not on Your Own Understanding (and Other Conversation-Enders)]] — *Data Over Dogma* ([[Dan McClellan]] + Dan Beecher); two interlocking arguments — (1) **Proverbs 3:5 as a thought-terminating cliché** ("lean not on your own understanding" weaponized to end questions; the abolitionist test; the verse belongs to the Job/Kohelet critical-wisdom stream, not anti-intellectualism) and **"read with the Holy Spirit" as textbook special pleading** (unfalsifiable privileged access; intuition "the same thing responsible for optical illusions"); (2) **Aleph-Tav / Bible-code mysticism debunked** — *et* is the definite-direct-object marker, not a hidden Christ; the Et Sefer movement's retreat to **Strong's** as the tell of not knowing Hebrew; the public-square line ("once you… affect how other people are living their lives… you're in my house"); same "wrong-spirit" move the wiki tracks in [[The Passion Translation]] (Bill Johnson) and McClellan's Jesus-in-OT source; strengthens **word-study-as-authority** + a **thought-terminating-clichés** candidate; source-caution (comedic polemical register; 9-snip partial coverage) (new 2026-07-18) - [[2026-07-06-sermon-brainwave-1095-feeding-jabbok-romans9|Sermon Brainwave 1095 — Feeding of the 5,000, Jacob at the Jabbok, Romans 9]] — *Sermon Brainwave* (Working Preacher / Luther Seminary; Karoline Lewis, Matt Skinner, Cody Sanders), lectionary prep for the Tenth Sunday after Pentecost (Aug 2); the wiki's **first Working Preacher source page** and a mainline/progressive **counterweight** to the NAR-heavy corpus; Matthew 14 feeding read as *splanchnizomai* gut-compassion + **anti-imperial political economy** ("you give them something to eat" vs. the emperor-feeds-the-people cornucopia coinage) + **Eucharistic** take–bless–break–give (a clearer communion image than the upper room) + concrete food-justice preaching (call the food shelf; distribute from the communion table, per Sara Miles's *Take This Bread*); Genesis 32 Jacob-at-the-Jabbok (wrestling as faith-forming; **the encounter is named, not the God**); Romans 9 with an explicit **anti-supersessionism** caution; reinforces the supersessionism concept candidate; **new entity candidate — Working Preacher / Sermon Brainwave**; source-caution (homiletics resource, 8-snip partial coverage) (new 2026-07-18) - [[2026-07-19-st-johns-ucc-esther-sadness-to-joy|St. John's UCC — Esther: From Sadness to Joy]] — sermon + order of worship, next installment of the [[St. John's UCC Chambersburg]] summer **Esther** series (Rev. Caroline Saxton; theme from Esther 9:22 "sorrow turned into joy"); **delivered content now captured** (post-sermon update 07-20; canonical home is the sermon note); texts Luke 1:68–79 (Benedictus), Psalm 124 (from [[The Inclusive Bible]]), Esther 7 + 9 (institution of Purim); Saxton reads the reversal through **proportionality and weaponized-scripture critique** — refuses to stop at 9:22, engages the massacre as hyperbole (Schifferdecker), and names the **Netanyahu/Amalek invocation over Gaza** as scripture misused; **standpoint hermeneutics on Psalm 124** (oppressor vs. oppressed); **divine hiddenness** resolved via the lector's "I don't know if the story happened this way, but I know that the story is true"; strong source material for [[Hermeneutical Genealogy]] + [[Lateral Transfer Risk]]; **liturgical-calendar collision** — Christian Purim-joy proclaimed during the Jewish **Nine Days** before **Tisha B'Av** (~July 23), pairing with the anti-supersessionism caution ingested the same cycle; **worship-standards data point** — "Shout to the Lord" (Hillsong/Zschech 1993) as Special Music, a **reappearance** of the 2026-04-26 evaluation (verdict stands); source-caution (progressive UCC; several attributions Whisper-garbled, pending verification; copyrighted lyrics not reproduced) (new 2026-07-18, delivered update 2026-07-20) - [[2026-07-20-churches-become-corporations-pia-hugo|Out of Control: When Churches Become Corporations — Pia Hugo (Ep. 659)]] — Pia Hugo + John Collins (YouTube Ep. 659); **structural NAR-lineage source** — reads church corruption as a predictable growth-stage dynamic (Eric Ries's *Incorruptible*: "the more successful an organization becomes, the more outside forces come into play") rather than individual villainy; Collins's hinge inversion ("Church was made for the people, not people made for the church"); the wiki's first **governance** through-line from [[William Branham]] (d. 1965) → the **Shepherding/Discipleship Movement** (Ern Baxter, Derek Prince) → People of Destiny International → Sovereign Grace Ministries, characterized as "a business religious pyramid scheme" — supplies the *organizational* mechanism under the [[Latter Rain]]/[[Manifested Sons of God]] doctrinal streams and the [[Five-Fold Ministry]]/[[Apostolic Authority]] hierarchy; the consequential claim is first-person — Larry Tomczak's *God, the Rod, and Your Child's Bod* as "a weapon to exert his abusive behavior" inside her marriage; [[DARVO]] **reverse** is structural ("gave my husband permission to physically abuse me"... "not even allowed to interfere"); links [[Church growth strategy]] ([[C. Peter Wagner]]/[[John Wimber]]) to [[Spiritual Abuse]]; introduces [[Shepherding Movement]] as a future stub; source-caution (secondhand throughout; TAG→PDI→Sovereign Grace lineage **explicitly flagged for independent verification**; "every church is a business" unscoped → `#fallacy/hasty-generalization`; sensitive child-abuse highlight dropped) (new 2026-07-20) - [[2026-07-20-prophetic-movements-validate-own-prophets|How Prophetic Movements Validate Their Own Prophets]] — video essay naming the **self-validation mechanism** of prophetic movements: planted/self-appointed corroborators ("one of those five stands up and says, 'I'm a prophet, too'... so generic... that matches what I said in some form") manufacture credibility, so **social proof substitutes for evidence** when the original claim is unfalsifiable; the load-bearing synthesis — "it really doesn't matter if one side is truly believing... the end result is the same" (sincere belief and fabrication yield identical outcomes, so intent is the wrong argument); research method is "trace the minor names" (George Warnock — garbled "George Waro", Myrtle Beall) who retroactively legitimized [[William Branham]] in the [[Latter Rain]]/[[Manifested Sons of God]] stream; the accountability mirror of [[Fallible Prophecy]] (no failable test → corroboration is the only currency); strengthens [[NAR Fallacy Taxonomy]] on social-proof-as-evidence; partial [[DARVO]] (supporting prophecies as reputational insulation; the minor-prophets "rising up" over serpent-seed as a possible face-saving "un-anointing"); source-caution (single video, garbled transcription; the Beall→Jim Jones "anointing" claim and the Warnock spelling/link both pending primary confirmation) (new 2026-07-20) - [[2026-07-20-untold-tragedy-jesus-movement-frisbee|The Untold Tragedy Behind the Jesus Movement]] — documentary-style video on the Jesus Movement's origins, centered on [[Lonnie Frisbee]]; the catalytic 1968 meeting with [[Chuck Smith]] ("I was not at all prepared for the love that this young man would radiate") seeds Calvary Chapel, Maranatha Music (first album "sold from car trunks... 160,000 copies" on Smith's own $2,500), and Explo '72 — the grassroots pre-history to the industrial account in [[2026-07-16-rise-of-christian-record-labels|The Rise of Christian Record Labels (CCM History, Part 3)]]; the "tragedy" is **institutional erasure** — Frisbee, gay, "died at 43 of AIDS, having been quietly written out of the official record by the institutions that he had helped build"; reusable atom "institutions credit the movement, not the marginalized founder"; **DEIB** — the same "credit the structure, erase the person" pattern the [[Spiritual Abuse]] cluster tracks, here on sexuality, connecting to [[Open and Affirming]] from an unexpected direction; Frisbee also seeded [[John Wimber]]'s Vineyard; source-caution (popular narration, no citations; **post hoc** inevitability framing overstates a single causal path; **hasty generalization** flattening the early catalog; erasure claim needs checking against Calvary Chapel's own histories) (new 2026-07-20) - [[2026-07-20-secret-code-bibles-first-word-debunked|The Secret Code in the Bible's First Word (Debunked)]] — linguistics explainer dismantling letter-meaning "Bible code" claims via Genesis's first word (*bereshit*); the load-bearing fact is that Hebrew script is **acrophonic** ("the character just indexes... the sound that used to start the word") so a letter marks a sound, not its ancestral pictograph's meaning — defeating the whole genre at once; the **aleph-tav** case (*et* is the untranslated direct-object marker, "because you don't translate the direct object marker, it's secret" — not an Alpha-and-Omega Christ code) underlies a published mistranslated Bible edition and the **Et Sefer** movement [[Dan McClellan]] critiques; a clean taxonomy — **bad interpretation of real data** (letter meanings, aleph-tav) vs. **invented data** (the fabricated DNA "10565 bond sequence"); the reusable **unfalsifiable-symbol test** (free reordering / selective inclusion / post-hoc assignment) also flags gematria, numerology, and Drosnin equidistant-letter-sequencing; same **word-study-as-authority** guardrail as [[2026-07-13-data-over-dogma-lean-not-proverbs-3-5|Data Over Dogma — Lean Not on Your Own Understanding (and Other Conversation-Enders)]] + [[2026-07-14-remnant-radio-cracking-the-time-code|The Remnant Radio — Exposing \"Cracking the Time Code\" (Candice Smithyman)]]; not a DARVO case (the hidden-knowledge appeal belongs to the *claims'* rhetoric, which the hosts name rather than enact); source-caution (popular debunk, standard linguistics but uncited; Drosnin-vs-letter-meaning scholarly comparison left open) (new 2026-07-20) - [[2026-07-14-greg-locke-federal-raid-claim|Feds Raid Greg Locke's Home? Finances Under Investigation]] — [[Greg Locke]] (Global Vision Bible Church, Mt. Juliet TN) on his own channel recounting a claimed pre-dawn federal raid ("60 federal agents surrounded our home") and bank-account cancellations amid a finances investigation; **media-literacy case study** — every substantive claim is uncorroborated first-person testimony from the subject of the investigation; reusable atom "testimony from the accused needs corroboration before it's fact"; the one checkable thread is the bank-closure claim; **DARVO-adjacent** persecution reframe ("the people that did... could very well be just as much victims as we are") converts a financial-accountability question into a persecution story; anchors the new [[Greg Locke]] entity; open verification items (which agency; any independent news coverage) logged as [[Media literacy — single-source claims]]; source-caution (self-published, no named agency/docket/third-party report — records a **claim**, not an event) (new 2026-07-20) - [[readwise-violent-take-it-by-force-taylor|The Violent Take It by Force (Taylor)]] — Matthew D. Taylor, *The Violent Take It by Force* (Broadleaf); the wiki's first dedicated source page for the **scholarly** NAR treatment already cited on [[start-here-new-apostolic-reformation|Concerned About the New Apostolic Reformation? Start Here]]; 15-highlight batch (synced 2026-07-23; earlier passes deferred it at 1 highlight); [[c-peter-wagner|C. Peter Wagner]] as "intellectual godfather," the **"NAR" name coined casually at a lunch** (Kay Hiramine), the [[Latter Rain]] → Ephesians 2:20 → [[Five-Fold Ministry]] lineage, "spiritual father/mother" deference as the structure that replaces denominations/seminaries ([[Apostolic Authority]]), **Paula White as Trump's faith gatekeeper** ("Rorschach test"), continuationist/cessationist definitions, Christian-nationalism↔patriarchy link; academic outside-view corroboration of claims previously held mostly from evangelical-cessationist critics ([[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]]); source-caution (highlight excerpts not full argument; focuses on the politicized wing) (new 2026-07-24) - [[2026-07-23-top-ten-errors-passion-translation-ward|Ward on Words — Top Ten Errors in The Passion Translation]] — Mark Ward ("Ward on Words," **cessationist** host) interviewing pastor David Fish (continuationist) on ten [[The Passion Translation]] passages; distinct from the continuationist-hosted [[2026-06-20-minor-prophets-is-the-passion-translation-finished|Minor Prophets — Is the Passion Translation Finished?]] by adding a **cessationist-host angle** + a **systematic ten-passage list**; the method charge — TPT abandons Greek/Hebrew for English paraphrases (du Toit's *Mirror Bible*, Andrew Roth, David Bauscher) and disputed "Aramaic insight," then presents the addition as original-language discovery; the Peshitta-is-translated-from-Greek point collapses the *paraklētos* "second savior" etymology (Paul Younan recanted it pre-publication); **Hebrews 12:6** "chastises"→"draws you to himself" imports the [[danny-silk|Danny Silk]] *Unpunishable*/[[Bethel Church]] frame into the text that rebukes it (independent corroboration of the Minor Prophets finding); the transferable rule "a good doctrine can still be an unlawful insertion"; feeds [[NAR Fallacy Taxonomy]] (word-study-as-authority) + worship-vetting; new entity candidates [[Mark Ward]] + David Fish; source-caution (adversarial analysis not peer-reviewed; hosts concede they aren't Syriac scholars) (new 2026-07-24) - [[2026-07-23-pivec-why-plagiarism-exposed-passion-translation|Holly Pivec — Why Did It Take Plagiarism to Expose The Passion Translation? (EP 37)]] — Holly Pivec (EP 37, *Counterfeit Kingdom* co-author); shifts the [[The Passion Translation]] cluster from *is the text corrupt?* to a **religious-epistemology** question — *why did concrete plagiarism trigger public concern when years of doctrinal criticism had not?* (communities act on checkable fraud faster than disputed theology, so scandal supplies an easier moral signal than discernment); restates the NAR **restoration timeline** (tongues 1900s → healing 1940s → prosperity 1970s → apostles/Seven Mountain) as a self-legitimizing frame, TPT as a "NAR translation" smuggling [[Seven Mountain Mandate]]/apostolic doctrine into the text, [[brian-simmons|Simmons]]'s apostle claim, prosperity as dominion **funding mechanism**, the Berean (Acts 17:11) standard; corroborates [[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]]; pairs with the Ward textual critique as the *why-now* complement; source-caution (author commentary, timing argument risks hindsight bias); beginner-page NO CHANGE (Pivec books already cited) (new 2026-07-25) - [[2026-07-24-world-harvest-word-of-faith-machine-663|Inside World Harvest Church and the Word of Faith Machine — Kenneth Berringer (Ep. 663)]] — Kenneth Berringer first-person testimony, John Collins "Word of Faith Machine" (Ep. 663, same series as [[2026-07-20-churches-become-corporations-pia-hugo|Ep. 659]]); **MLM↔high-control-religion crossover** (Amway + The Way International → [[Word of Faith]]); the transferable **giving mechanism** — "convince people the money is God's, then that you are the interface between God and man… a gift to a prophet gets a prophet's reward" (Matt 10:41 recruited to route money to leaders), concrete ~$10k "beaver blanket" gift; a witnessed leg-lengthening "miracle" later doubted (disconfirmation), restricted outside teaching (information control), procedural exit advice; continues Ep. 659's structural frame with the financial/experiential view from the pew; feeds [[Spiritual Abuse]]/[[Apostolic Authority]]; entity candidates John Collins + Berringer, [[Word of Faith]] concept-stub flagged; source-caution (first-person; resemblance→lineage, harm→motive leaps; distinct from Chambersburg [[research-world-harvest-outreach-nar|World Harvest Outreach]]) (new 2026-07-25) - [[2026-07-23-wired-word-shared-lay-ministry|Wired Word — Shared Lay Ministry and Spiritual Gifts (for 7/26/2026)]] — Wired Word adult-ed guide (ed. 7/26/2026); a Maine synagogue's year of **lay-led ministry** (70+ laypeople during a rabbinical vacancy; congregation *grew*) framed as the **priesthood of all believers** — clergy equip rather than gatekeep; second ingested Wired Word after [[2026-04-23-wired-word-finishing-well-church-closures|Wired Word — Finishing Well in a Time of Church Closures]]; mainline/[[United Church of Christ]] ecclesiology, pastoral relevance to [[St. John's UCC Chambersburg]]; sits opposite the concentrated [[Apostolic Authority]] model — the wiki now holds **both poles of the "who holds ministry?" question from one week's intake**; carries the source's own DEIB caution (don't reduce a Jewish congregation to an object lesson); [[Priesthood of All Believers]] concept-stub flagged (new 2026-07-25) - [[2026-07-28-leaving-the-message-stage-deliverance-666|Stage Deliverance: How Fear Replaced Faith — Collins & Ross (Ep. 666)]] — John Collins + Chino Ross (Ep. 666, same series as [[2026-07-24-world-harvest-word-of-faith-machine-663|663]]/[[2026-07-20-churches-become-corporations-pia-hugo|659]]) opening a series on **Hobart Freeman**'s demons-and-deliverance teaching; the **"stage version of deliverance"** — a scriptural concept turned into a performance where one figure claims control over a room's spirits, creating **dependency by design** ("you've been trained to believe the human is your protection, not God"); [[john-alexander-dowie|Dowie]]→Bosworth→[[william-branham|Branham]] lineage and the circular-reasoning fix for deaths in healing homes; **deliverance harder to document than healing** (invisible mental-health damage forty years on); Ross's transferable hermeneutic (read-critically≠criticize; the mountain question on Mark 11:23; *diabolos*/*daimonion*; fear-is-not-a-demon on 2 Tim 1:7); entity candidates John Collins/Hobart Freeman/Chino Ross + a deliverance-ministry concept flagged; source-caution (ex-adherent advocacy; lineage asserted; NAR-continuity claim unanswered) (new 2026-07-29) - [[2026-07-21-taylor-christian-supremacy-markers|The Identifying Markers of Christian Supremacy — Matthew D. Taylor]] — Matthew D. Taylor (author of [[readwise-violent-take-it-by-force-taylor|The Violent Take It by Force]]), intro excerpt of *Defying Tyrants*; the load-bearing **definition** ("Christian supremacy… is the idea that Christians are entitled to power over other people") and the **cross-tradition vocabulary map** (Catholic integralism, Orthodox phyletism, Protestant [[dominionism]]/[[seven-mountain-mandate|Seven Mountains]]/theonomy) the wiki should hold; the theological-not-political pivot (defensible + conveniently book-justifying); the unfalsifiable victim-inversion marker = [[darvo|DARVO]] under another name; contradiction flagged on Taylor's phyletism gloss vs. the 1872 condemnation; Taylor now past entity threshold; source-caution (book-promo excerpt, homiletic register, no named cases) (new 2026-07-29) - [[2026-06-15-taylor-christian-nationalism-zionism-antisemitism|How Christian Zionism and Christian Antisemitism Are Tearing MAGA Apart — Matthew D. Taylor]] — Matthew D. Taylor, part 4 of his Christian-nationalism series; the **category correction** (asking which side "the Christian nationalists" are on has no answer — they're on both — so a monolithic [[christian-nationalism|Christian nationalism]] is malformed); the durable historical claim that **philosemitism and antisemitism are two sides of one coin** (the "parting of the ways" ambivalence, [[eschatology]]-and-Israel as the fracture line); the newer **charismatic conquest-oriented Zionism** vs. twentieth-century Dispensationalism; [[douglas-wilson|Doug Wilson]] on replacement theology; supersessionism/Christian-Zionism concept candidates; source-caution (positioned commentary, causal claims marked as inference, no Jewish voice) (new 2026-07-29) - [[2026-07-28-mcclellan-genesis-1-11-david-carr|Where Did Genesis 1–11 Come From? — McClellan interviews David Carr]] — [[dan-mcclellan|Dan McClellan]] interviews Hebrew Bible scholar **David Carr** (*Holy Resilience*) on Genesis 1–11; the Bible's formation as texts written "in the furnace of communal trauma"; **Genesis 1 as counter-writing** to the Garden of Eden (the intended replacement became the prologue); scribal transmission on older curriculum literature, Genesis 1 as an *Enuma Elish*-shaped story with Marduk erased (feeds [[divine-council|Divine Council]]); a canon that **preserved contradiction is making a statement about itself**; same read-to-understand hermeneutic Ross reaches in Ep. 666; David Carr entity candidate; source-caution (trauma-frame hard to falsify) (new 2026-07-29) - [[2026-07-29-mcclellan-masturbation-not-condemned|Does the Bible Actually Condemn Masturbation? — Dan McClellan]] — [[dan-mcclellan|Dan McClellan]] short; the Bible never addresses masturbation, used as a worked example of proof-texting; **ritual impurity is a state, not a sin** ([[purity-culture|Purity Culture]] category error); argument-from-silence used correctly (the most wasteful act is not the most prohibited); the portable claim — **interpretive precedence tracks a text's usefulness for group boundary maintenance, not its exegetical weight**; purity-vs-morality concept candidate; source-caution (short-form; author field lists "YouTube") (new 2026-07-29) ## Analysis - [[Lint 2026-06-15]] — Lint pass 2026-06-15 (faith-and-theology cycle); 3 content pages added (Bethel platform-problem source, Tamice Spencer-Helms source + entity) + bethel-church entity and index updated; 2 forbidden words fixed (`elevate`→`promote`); 0 new dead links (source cross-links use resolving-basename aliases); 0 real orphans; complete frontmatter; Ecclesiastes 1–4 translation scaffolds noted-not-ingested; page count 190 (new 2026-06-15) - [[Lint 2026-06-11]] — Lint pass 2026-06-11 (maintenance cycle); 8 new pages ingested (4 sources + 4 entities) from the 24h Readwise sync — Rededicate 250/WBHR, two Dan McClellan videos, UCC Manual on Ministry; 0 forbidden-word violations and complete frontmatter on all new pages; 4 new intentional dead-link stubs; page count 179; flagged lint self-referential false-positive noise (log.md + Lint files enumerate the wordlist) (new 2026-06-11) - [[Lint 2026-06-09]] — Lint pass 2026-06-09 (automated; first run after ~12-day gap); 8 new pages from a large Readwise batch dominated by [[The Passion Translation]] (concept + Brian Simmons/Mike Winger/Charles Fox Parham entities + 4 source pages); 0 forbidden-word violations; 7 new intentional dead-link stubs; Habitat/Trinity thread correction; page count 169 (new 2026-06-09) - [[Lint 2026-05-27]] — Lint pass 2026-05-27 (automated); 3 new pages (Theodicy concept, Spiritual Warfare Theology concept stub, Life After Doom source); 2 source pages updated (NL442 post-service, NL443 date corrected); [[Theodicy]] and [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] dead links resolved (−2); [[Brian McLaren]] entity dead link introduced (+1); first full-file dead-link scan: 38 actionable dead links (prior curated: 28); 1 forbidden-word violation resolved; page total 135 (new 2026-05-27) - [[Lint 2026-05-26]] — Lint pass 2026-05-26 (automated); 3 pages indexed (Pivec/Geivett NAR source, World Harvest Outreach partial, Kelly Latimore entity); [[Kelly Latimore]] dead link resolved (−1); [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] new dead link (+1); dead link total 29; page count 122 (new 2026-05-26) - [[Lint 2026-05-23]] — Lint pass 2026-05-23; May 24 Pentecost bulletin ingested (1 source page); 3 hymns evaluated + added to Worship Songs Evaluated; 1 new dead link (Kelly Latimore entity); dead link total 29; page count 119 (new 2026-05-23) - [[Lint 2026-05-21]] — Lint pass 2026-05-21; 0 new vault content; 2 orphans resolved (NAR Fallacy Taxonomy, Bethel/Wolf source); 10 forbidden-word fixes; 2 new true dead links (Lateral Transfer Risk, Unpunishable); dead link total 28; page count 117 (new 2026-05-21) - [[Lint 2026-05-18]] — Lint pass 2026-05-18; vault not mounted (5-day gap May 14–17); Koinonia concept page drafted (1 dead link resolved, 26 remaining); James 3 watch closed; 0 forbidden-word violations; 0 orphans; page count 114 (new 2026-05-18) - [[Lint 2026-05-13]] — Lint pass 2026-05-13; no new vault content; 0 forbidden-word violations; orphan resolved (Lint 2026-05-06 added to index); page count corrected to 112; 0 dead links introduced; 27 stubs unchanged (new 2026-05-13) - [[Lint 2026-05-12]] — Lint pass 2026-05-12; no new vault content; 0 forbidden-word violations; 2 dead links retroactively identified from last cycle (Koinonia, Theodicy); running stub total 27; 0 orphans (new 2026-05-12) - [[Lint 2026-05-11]] — Lint pass 2026-05-11; NL444 sermon notes ingested; NL442 stub created; Caroline Saxton entity updated; 1 forbidden-word fix (paradigm → pattern); 0 dead links introduced; 0 orphans (new 2026-05-11) - [[Lint 2026-05-10]] — Lint pass 2026-05-10; bulletin ingested (NL444 corrected from NL441); 3 Readwise source pages added (Bessey, Riley, Gunnemann); 7 songs evaluated (+7 total now 25); 1 forbidden-word fix; 2 dead links resolved; 0 orphans (new 2026-05-10) - [[Lint 2026-05-09]] — Lint pass 2026-05-09; no new vault content in 24h window; NL441 prep ingest (1 source page); "elevated"→"heightened" violation resolved; 0 forbidden-word violations; 20 dead links unchanged; 0 orphans (new 2026-05-09) - [[Lint 2026-05-08]] — Lint pass 2026-05-08; Afro-Christian Convention (Delk) Readwise ingest; 3 new pages (source, Yvonne Delk entity, Afro-Christian Convention body entity); 0 forbidden-word violations; 20 dead links unchanged; 0 orphans (new 2026-05-08) - [[Lint 2026-05-07]] — Lint pass 2026-05-07; May 3 sermon analysis completed (48/65; liberationist economic hermeneutic); source page and Caroline Saxton entity updated; 0 forbidden-word violations in original prose; 20 dead links unchanged; 0 orphans (new 2026-05-07) - [[Lint 2026-05-06]] — Lint pass 2026-05-06; CCLI Reporting/Royalty Flow and Decisional Conversion concept pages written; 0 forbidden-word violations; dead links resolved; 0 orphans (retroactively added to index 2026-05-13 — page existed but was missing from index) - [[Lint 2026-05-05]] — Lint pass 2026-05-05; maintenance-only cycle; 3 concept pages written (Musical Sacramentality, Word-and-Table Liturgy, Covenant Renewal Worship); 0 forbidden-word violations; 3 dead links resolved; 0 orphans - [[Lint 2026-05-04]] — Lint pass 2026-05-04; maintenance-only cycle; 2 concept pages written (Dominionism, DARVO); 0 forbidden-word violations; 2 dead links resolved; 0 orphans - [[Lint 2026-05-03]] — Lint pass 2026-05-03; 2 new pages (May 3 sermon source, Lint); 2 hymns added to Worship Songs Evaluated; 0 new dead links; 0 forbidden-word violations - [[Lint 2026-05-02]] — Lint pass 2026-05-02; 2 new pages (Five-Fold Ministry, C. Peter Wagner); 2 dead-link clusters resolved; 1 new stub (DARVO) - [[Lint 2026-05-01]] — Lint pass 2026-05-01; 3 new pages (IHOPKC, Apostolic Authority, Mike Bickle stub); 2 forbidden-word fixes; 2 dead-link clusters resolved - [[Lint 2026-04-30]] — Lint pass 2026-04-30; 1 new concept page (The Inclusive Bible); 9-way dead-link resolution; 2 stubs cataloged - [[Lint 2026-04-29]] — Lint pass 2026-04-29 (maintenance-only; 3 defects fixed; 2 new stubs cataloged) - [[Lint 2026-04-28]] — Lint pass 2026-04-28 (maintenance-only; 4 forbidden-word fixes; 5 new stubs cataloged) - [[Lint 2026-04-27]] — Lint pass 2026-04-27; 1 new source page, 2 entities (new + updated), 2 song evaluations added - [[Lint 2026-04-26]] — Lint pass 2026-04-26 (maintenance-only; 3 defects fixed) - [[Lint 2026-04-25]] — Lint pass 2026-04-25 - [[NAR Worship Critique Traditions]] — Reformed-cessationist vs. progressive-mainline critiques of NAR worship; convergence and divergence - [[Worship Songs Evaluated]] — Living doc of songs considered for St. John's UCC - [[Lint 2026-04-22]] — Lint pass 2026-04-22 - [[Lint 2026-04-23]] — Lint pass 2026-04-23 ## Timelines *(No pages yet.)* ## Worship Theology - [[Worship Songs Evaluated]] — primary living document - [[Praise and Worship Theology]] — canonical framework analysis - [[Inclusive Language Hymnody]] — positive-alternative tradition - [[NAR Worship Critique Traditions]] — comparative critique analysis - [[Hillsongization]] — Marti's sociological frame - [[Blended Worship]] — convergence frame; liturgical container for vetted repertoire (new 2026-04-22) - [[Worship Music Vetting Projects]] — cross-tradition CCLI-evaluation catalog (new 2026-04-22) - [[Worship Song Vetting Rubric St Johns UCC]] — actionable 4-tier scoring rubric for St. John's UCC (new 2026-04-24) - [[readwise-worship-industry-economics-cluster|Worship Industry Economics Cluster]] — the money chain behind the songbook; supplies the credit-list vetting question (new 2026-09-04) ## Open Threads ### Closed this cycle (2026-04-27) - [[2026-04-26 St Johns UCC Paul and Silas]] source page added (Acts 16 / NL442; spirituals tradition; prophetic justice). - [[Sweet Honey in the Rock]] entity page created. - [[Caroline Saxton]] entity updated with April 26 sermon themes. - [[Worship Songs Evaluated]] updated: "Shout to the Lord" (Conditionally Passed) and "How Can I Keep from Singing" (Passed) added. ### Closed this cycle (2026-04-25) - ~~[[Christian Feminism Today]] (EEWC-CFT) entity stub~~ — **closed.** Full entity with feminist orientation, publication history, and UCC context. Closes dead link from 5+ pages. - ~~[[Bryan Sirchio]] entity stub~~ — **closed.** Full entity with 6 Marks framework, CMP network, and St. John's UCC relevance. - ~~[[Brian Hehn]] entity stub~~ — **closed.** Full entity with ecumenical CCLI meta-project scope, UCC gap analysis, and contact guidance. - [[Christian Nationalism]] concept stub added — primary source (Hobbs forthcoming) still needed for expansion. ### Closed this cycle (2026-04-24) - ~~Worship-team one-page screening checklist~~ — **closed.** [[Worship Song Vetting Rubric St Johns UCC]] provides the full 4-tier, 7-category rubric. - ~~Valerie Hobbs entity stub~~ — **closed.** Full entity with manipulation framework and theolinguistics methodology. - ~~Monique Ingalls entity stub~~ — **closed.** Full entity with five-modes-of-congregating framework. - ~~Center for Congregational Song entity stub~~ — **closed.** Brian Hehn; ecumenical meta-list; UCC gap named. - ~~Convergence Music Project — Bryan Sirchio missing as founder~~ — **closed.** Updated CMP entity page with Sirchio, full artist list. - ~~UCC Open and Affirming Coalition worship resource deep-read~~ — **partially closed.** §2 of compendium summarizes ONA resources; full standalone source page still open. - [[2026-04-26 St Johns UCC Paul and Silas]] — 4th Sunday of Easter; NL442; Acts 16:16–34; spirituals tradition as hermeneutic; prophetic justice (Birmingham, Standing Rock); 57/65 sermon rubric (new 2026-04-27) - [[2026-04-24 Worship Music Vetting Compendium]] source page added. ### Closed previous cycle (2026-04-23) - ~~Telos and Finishing Well concept page~~ — **closed.** New concept anchoring mainline ecclesiology-in-decline framing. - ~~Sisters of Charity of New York entity stub~~ — **closed.** Case study for [[Telos and Finishing Well]]. - [[2026-04-23 Wired Word Finishing Well Church Closures]] source page added. ### Closed previous cycle (2026-04-22) - ~~United Church of Christ entity page~~ — **closed.** Closes 2026-04-14 dead-link finding. - ~~Blended Worship concept page~~ — **closed.** Convergence framing anchored. - ~~Worship Music Vetting Projects concept page~~ — **closed.** Cross-tradition catalog of UMC / Calvin / NAR-critical / G3 projects. - ~~Calvin Institute of Christian Worship entity~~ — **closed** (stub with CCLI-vetting framing). - ~~United Methodist Church Discipleship Ministries entity~~ — **closed** (stub). - ~~Reformed Worship magazine entity~~ — **closed** (stub). - ~~Kathryn Ritsema Roelofs entity~~ — **closed** (stub; Calvin CCLI contributor). ### Closed previous cycle (2026-04-21) - ~~Bethel Church entity page~~ — **closed.** Full page with Bethel Music, BSSM, and NAR-adjacency coverage. - ~~Hillsong entity page~~ — **closed.** - ~~Bill Johnson entity page~~ — **closed.** - ~~Progressive Christianity concept page~~ — **closed.** Seven-commitment framework with named voices, comparison to NAR, hermeneutical toolbox. - ~~Inclusive Language Hymnody concept page~~ — **closed.** UCC New Century Hymnal anchored. - ~~Hillsongization concept page~~ — **closed.** - ~~Praise and Worship Theology concept page~~ — **closed.** ### Closed this cycle (2026-04-30) - ~~[[The Inclusive Bible]]~~ — **closed.** Concept page written: Priests for Equality (2007), YHWH restoration, gender-expansive divine imagery, "Human One" for Son of Man, documented use at St. John's UCC (Psalm 30, April 19; Psalm 34, April 26), evangelical/progressive contradiction callout, DEIB lens. Resolved 9-page dead-link cluster. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-06) - ~~[[CCLI Reporting and Royalty Flow]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: CCLI license types (CCL, Streaming Plus, Recording), royalty flow mechanics, Top 100 data limitations (Hehn), OneLicense alternative, practical implications for St. John's UCC, theological implications of royalty chain. Resolves dead link from index Open Threads. - ~~[[Decisional Conversion]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: Finney's revivalist origins, NAR amplification through apostolic-authority overlay, progressive UCC counter-model (formation over decision, community as constitutive of conversion), Caroline Saxton's "conversion as draft" framing across three Acts sermons (Paul's conversion, Philippian jailer, Areopagus), household baptism (*oikos*) thread, DEIB analysis of decisional pressure. Resolves dead link from index Open Threads and from 3 existing source/entity pages. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-05) - ~~[[Musical Sacramentality]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: the P&W claim that music mediates divine presence; Lim/Ruth/Ingalls/Hobbs scholarly frame; Reformed Regulative Principle critique; progressive pastoral-exclusion critique (grief, disability, deconstruction); diagnostic without dismissing emotional worship; source gaps. Resolves dead link flagged 2026-04-28 (2+ references). - ~~[[Word-and-Table Liturgy]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: fourfold mainline shape (Gathering, Word, Table, Sending); Justin Martyr / ecumenical recovery; structural contrast with P&W; UCC practice at St. John's; song-slot implications; DEIB argument that presence is gift not achievement. Resolves dead link flagged 2026-04-28 (2+ references). - ~~[[Covenant Renewal Worship]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: five-movement Reformed shape (Call, Consecration, Instruction, Communion, Commission) from Exodus 19–24; confession as structural element; Table as constitutive; presider-as-herald vs. apostolic-authority mediator; convergence with progressive mainline at structural level; source gaps. Resolves dead link flagged 2026-04-21 / cataloged 2026-04-30. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-04) - ~~[[Dominionism]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: Gen. 1:28 / Matt. 28:19 scriptural anchors, Seven Mountain Mandate (Wagner), three-tradition critique, NAR apostolic dominionism vs. soft cultural vs. reconstructionist, structural link to Apostolic Authority and Five-Fold Ministry, DEIB assessment, source gaps. Resolves highest-priority dead link (6+ references). - ~~[[DARVO]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: Freyd's three-move sequence, structural amplification in apostolic-authority contexts, three documented patterns (prophecy failure / abuse disclosure / deconstruction exit), clinical context (betrayal trauma theory), diagnostic distinction from genuine disagreement, faith-and-doubt intersection. Resolves stub cataloged 2026-05-02. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-07) - ~~[[2026-05-03 St Johns UCC Paul at Athens]] sermon analysis pending~~ — **closed 2026-05-07.** Source page promoted from bulletin stage to full analysis (48/65). Liberationist economic hermeneutic named as central homiletical move (persecution = market disruption, not theological threat). NAR contrast analysis documented. Caroline Saxton entity updated with two new cumulative preaching themes. Four consecutive maintenance-cycle flag resolved. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-03) - [[2026-05-03 St Johns UCC Paul at Athens]] — source page created; NL443 bulletin; Acts 17:16–31 + John 14:15–21; natural theology / divine immanence; two hymn evaluations added (Watts #19, Winter #575). Full sermon analysis completed 2026-05-07 (score 48/65). ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-02) - ~~[[Five-Fold Ministry]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: Eph. 4:11 three-tradition critique, NAR governance hierarchy, structural accountability gap, DARVO as structural outcome, worship-theology connection. Resolved 4-page dead-link cluster (NAR entity, IHOPKC, Apostolic Authority, Mike Bickle stub). - ~~[[C. Peter Wagner]]~~ — **closed.** Full entity page: Fuller Seminary missiologist, coined NAR label, second-Reformation theory, International Coalition of Apostles, seven mountains dominionism. Resolved 2-page dead-link cluster (NAR entity, Apostolic Authority). - ~~[[DARVO]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-04.** Full concept page: Freyd's framework, structural amplification in apostolic-authority settings, documented NAR patterns, betrayal trauma clinical context. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-01) - ~~[[IHOPKC]]~~ — **closed.** Full entity page: Harp and Bowl model, theological framework, 4-criteria harm assessment, 2023 Bickle abuse investigation, worship-vetting relevance. Resolved stub cataloged 2026-04-29. - ~~[[Apostolic Authority]]~~ — **closed.** Full concept page: NAR claim, three-tradition critique (NAR/cessationist/historical-critical), four harm patterns, ecumenical contrast with UCC congregational polity. Resolved stub cataloged 2026-04-28. - [[Mike Bickle]] — stub created to resolve IHOPKC frontmatter dead link; full development pending primary-source ingest. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-08) - [[readwise-afro-christian-convention-yvonne-delk|Afro-Christian Convention — Yvonne Delk (Readwise Highlights)]] — **partial ingest complete.** Source page written from 2 Readwise highlights. Key claims: (1) white theology institutionalized racism via "spiritual anointing to white power and privilege" (Delk); (2) Afro-Christian worship as culturally-rooted gift to the UCC (Alston via Delk). [[Yvonne Delk]] entity stub created. [[Afro-Christian Convention (body)]] entity stub created. Full book ingest remains open. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-09) - ~~`decisional-conversion.md:52` forbidden-word flag~~ — **resolved.** "elevated emotional state" → "heightened emotional state." Carried from Lint 2026-05-07. - [[2026-05-10 St Johns UCC Partnership in Gospel]] — **prep ingest complete.** NL441 source stub written from 7 Working Preacher podcast snips. Key themes: *koinonia*, imprisonment reframed as gospel advance, pastoral caution on suffering, letters as communal events, joy as resilience, NL442 Christ Hymn preview. Sermon notes and recording pending; full analysis after May 10 service. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-10) - ~~**NL441 designation error**~~ — **resolved.** Source page for May 10 service corrected from NL441 (podcast episode number) to NL444 (Narrative Lectionary service designation). NL designation error corrected across frontmatter, title, and all prose. - [[2026-05-10 St Johns UCC Partnership in Gospel]] — **bulletin ingested.** Full order of worship incorporated: hymns, Mother's Day litany (Patty Lawrence), "Worthy" responsive reading (Bobby Jo Valentine), hermeneutical notes on Phil 1:1 plural episcopate and Phil 1:15–18 dual-use passage. 7 songs evaluated (4 hymns Passed, 3 contemporary pieces noted/passed). Sermon notes and rubric scoring still pending recording. - [[readwise-field-notes-for-the-wilderness-bessey|Field Notes for the Wilderness (Sarah Bessey)]] — new source page; Bessey deconstruction memoir; 18 highlights; connects to [[Deconstruction]] concept page (still open stub). - [[readwise-black-liturgies-riley|Black Liturgies (Cole Arthur Riley)]] — new source page; Cole Arthur Riley; 4 highlights; connects to [[Praise and Worship Theology]], [[Musical Sacramentality]], and DEIB threads. - [[readwise-shaping-of-the-ucc-gunnemann|The Shaping of the United Church of Christ (Louis H. Gunnemann)]] — new source page; Gunnemann UCC history; 3 highlights; [[United Church of Christ]] entity updated with "united and uniting" framing and founding context. - [[Worship Songs Evaluated]] — updated: 7 songs added from May 10 service (Hymns #310, #281, #704, #706 Passed; "This is the Day" noted; "Worthy" by Valentine passed as responsive reading; "I Need Thee Every Hour" Passed). Total evaluated: **25** hymns/songs (was 18 last cycle; +7 this cycle including the 4 new PD hymns). ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-11) - ~~**NL444 sermon notes**~~ — **closed 2026-05-11.** Full sermon notes ingested from vault (`Sermon Notes/2026-05-10.md`). Key findings: "partnership not domination" as the sermon's sharpest anti-NAR claim; Craddock empire-reading deployed; unity/uniformity distinction; three local partnership applications (NETWork, food insecurity, Habitat). Phil 1:15–18 and Phil 1:1 plural episcopate left undeveloped — documented in hermeneutical audit. 13-category rubric scoring still pending YouTube recording. - ~~**NL442 source stub**~~ — **closed 2026-05-11.** Prep stub created (`sources/2026-05-17-st-johns-ucc-christ-hymn.md`) from 6 Working Preacher snips. Key themes: kenosis as counter-imperial choice, Christ hymn as pre-Pauline liturgical song, *phronein* as directed verb, *eritheia* criterion completing the Phil 1:15–18 loop. - **[[Caroline Saxton]] entity updated** — May 10 sermon analysis section added; "partnership not domination" named as sharpest anti-NAR claim in corpus; Habitat for Humanity thread opened. - **1 forbidden-word fix** — `paradigm` → `pattern` in NL442 source page. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-18) - ~~**Koinonia concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-18.** Full concept page written from NL444 and NL442 source pages. Phil 1:5/2:1 as koinonia brackets around the Christ hymn; material dimension (Phil 4:15–18); partnership-not-domination as gospel's structural mode; *eritheia* criterion (Phil 2:3) completing the Phil 1:15–18 hermeneutical loop; NAR contradiction callout (apostolic-authority community vs. Pauline horizontal koinonia); local embodiment at St. John's UCC (NETWork, food insecurity, Habitat). Dead link count: 27 → 26. - **James 3 watch** — **closed 2026-05-18.** Watch flag set 2026-05-11: "if no James 3 sermon notes appear by May 17, remove from active watch." Vault not mounted; no notes detected. Flag retired. Re-open if vault content surfaces in future cycle. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-13) - ~~**Lint 2026-05-06 orphan**~~ — **resolved.** `analysis/Lint 2026-05-06.md` existed on disk but was missing from `index.md` Analysis section. Added retroactively. Page count corrected to 111. ### Closed this cycle (2026-05-23) - [[2026-05-24 St Johns UCC Pentecost]] — source page ingested from `Sermon Notes/2026-05-24.md` (Pentecost Sunday bulletin created 2026-05-22). Dual-text pneumatology (John 20 + Acts 2), Joel 2 hermeneutics, Illustrated Ministry liturgical texts, Kelly Latimore icon notes, worship-theology connections. - **Worship Songs Evaluated updated** — Hymn 225 "On Pentecost They Gathered" (PASS), Hymn 229 "Let Every Christian Pray" (PASS), Thomas Dorsey "Precious Lord, Take My Hand" (PASS). Total evaluated songs: **31** (+3 this cycle; was 28 after Lint 2026-05-21). ### Open and active **New this cycle (2026-07-18 — automated):** - **4 new source pages + 2 updates.** New: [[2026-07-17-mcclellan-let-us-make-man-divine-council|Dan McClellan — Let US Make Man in OUR Image?!?]], [[2026-07-13-data-over-dogma-lean-not-proverbs-3-5|Data Over Dogma — Lean Not on Your Own Understanding (and Other Conversation-Enders)]], [[2026-07-06-sermon-brainwave-1095-feeding-jabbok-romans9|Sermon Brainwave 1095 — Feeding of the 5,000, Jacob at the Jabbok, Romans 9]], [[2026-07-19-st-johns-ucc-esther-sadness-to-joy|St. John's UCC — Esther: From Sadness to Joy]]. Updated: [[Dan McClellan]] (2 sources + 2 position bullets; `updated`→07-18), [[Worship Songs Evaluated]] ("Shout to the Lord" reappearance logged 07-19; verdict stands). Content pages now: **sources 104** (+4). - **⭐ The cycle's finding — a same-day McClellan pair on the *epistemology* of interpretation.** [[2026-07-17-mcclellan-let-us-make-man-divine-council|Dan McClellan — Let US Make Man in OUR Image?!?]] dismantles a doctrinal reading (Genesis 1:26 = Trinity) on historical grounds; [[2026-07-13-data-over-dogma-lean-not-proverbs-3-5|Data Over Dogma — Lean Not on Your Own Understanding (and Other Conversation-Enders)]] dismantles the *defense* that protects such readings — "you can only understand scripture with the Spirit" named as "the definition of special pleading." Two halves of one argument, ingested together — the historical case and the epistemic one. This is the **same "wrong-spirit" social-identity move** the 07-17 cycle documented in Bill Johnson's deflection of TPT critics; it now has a clean, self-aware statement of the mechanism. - **⭐ Concept threshold crossed — divine council.** The [[2026-07-02-mcclellan-image-of-god-divine-council|Dan McClellan — What Does It Mean to Be Created \"In God's Image\"?]] page explicitly parked `concepts/divine-council.md` "below threshold... one more focused source would justify" it. The 07-17 video **is** that source — a dedicated treatment, not a sub-point. Two focused sources now do real interpretive work against Trinity proof-texting. **Top concept recommendation for the next directed session** (held here per the automated envelope). - **Unplanned convergence — divine hiddenness.** Three of four sources touch God-not-directly-named: **Esther** never names God (bulletin); **Jacob** names the encounter, not the God, at the Jabbok (Sermon Brainwave); the **divine-council "us"** hides a pantheon inside a singular narrative (McClellan). Filed as an observation, not forced into a synthesis. - **Unplanned convergence — Jewish-Christian sensitivity, from two directions.** The Esther bulletin proclaims Purim-joy during the Jewish **Nine Days** before **Tisha B'Av**; Sermon Brainwave 1095 carries an explicit **anti-supersessionism** caution on Romans 9. Two independent prompts, same cycle, toward careful Christian handling of Judaism — reinforcing the standing **supersessionism** concept candidate. - **Concept/entity candidates strengthened (held for a directed pass, per envelope):** **divine council** (threshold crossed, above); **Working Preacher / Sermon Brainwave** (new entity candidate — cited across many bulletin pages, now with a dedicated source); **word-study-as-authority-move** (Strong's misuse, strengthened again) and a **thought-terminating-clichés / conversation-enders** concept candidate (Proverbs 3:5); **supersessionism** (reinforced). No new entity/concept pages created. - **Skipped / off-domain (24h window):** two title-plausible near-misses caught by opening them — **"Better Way"** (nomad.blog; WordPress 7.1 release-leadership reflection, not theology) and **"Searching for Paradise"** (TED Radio Hour; secular recovery/travel/megafires — "paradise" is geographic, not eschatological). Also the large WordPress/AI/tech Readwise batch (~90 files: WP 7.1 Beta, Gutenberg Changelog, Syntax/ShopTalk, Hard Fork, Data Over Dogma **counted in**, etc.), the meeting note (experiment-showcase), and all Loop Reports / Site Health / Sermon-Notes-template files. **raw/** empty; **Bible/** and **Religious Research/** unchanged (0 in window). Recurring on-domain shows whose *this* episode was new: Data Over Dogma and Working Preacher (both ingested). - **Automation note (unattended run):** the ingest workflow (CLAUDE.md step 2) normally pauses for Courtney's confirmation before writing pages. This is a scheduled run with no human present, so per the scheduled-task rule I proceeded autonomously on the 4 in-window on-domain sources and recorded the choices here — consistent with every prior automated cycle. Scope held to the established envelope: **source pages + entity/concept citations + index + log only.** All new entity and concept pages (divine council chief among them) held for a directed pass. **New this cycle (2026-07-17 — automated):** - **6 new source pages + 2 updates — the largest on-domain window since 06-09.** New: [[2026-07-16-bill-johnson-defends-passion-translation|Bill Johnson Defends The Passion Translation (Rediscover Bethel)]], [[2026-07-16-bethel-alumni-calls-out-passion-translation|Why This Bethel Alumni Is Calling Out the Passion Translation]], [[2026-07-16-remnant-radio-continuationists-cessationists|The Remnant Radio — Why Continuationists and Cessationists Keep Talking Past Each Other]], [[2026-07-16-rise-of-christian-record-labels|The Rise of Christian Record Labels (CCM History, Part 3)]], [[2026-07-16-off-code-lecrae-piper-confession|Off Code — Reacting to Lecrae's John Piper Confession]], [[2026-07-16-wired-word-religion-health-report|The Wired Word — Religious People Live Longer and Better, Says Report (7/19/2026)]]. Updated: [[Bill Johnson]] (first primary source; new TPT section; Open Threads re-scoped), [[The Passion Translation]] (2 sources; DARVO documented; two-tier confirmed; defense-and-eyewitness section; Source gaps re-scoped). Content pages now: entities 72 + concepts 43 + **sources 100** + analysis 65 + index + cross-wiki. - **⭐ The cycle's finding — a matched pair on TPT, ingested the same day.** [[The Passion Translation]] has been a critic-corpus page since 06-09; its own Source gaps said so. It now holds **both sides**: [[Bill Johnson]] defending TPT in his own voice, and a BSSM graduate describing what it did to her. Three contradictions fall out. (1) **DARVO moves from anticipated to documented** — the concept page *predicted* deny/attack/reverse-victim; Johnson performs all three on camera. (2) **The stated limit is not the movement's practice** — Johnson says "I don't use it as a proof text" while the wiki has Parsley's congregation chanting TPT's inserted Psalm 81:10 decree and Daystar quoting TPT as Scripture unattributed. (3) **The epistemic-privilege inversion** — Johnson says critics are educated elitists out of touch with the "brand new believer"; the alumni says the *absence* of that education is what left her defenseless, and educated critics rescued the very readers he claims to protect. Same fact, opposite valence. - **Unresolved discrepancy, deliberately left open.** Johnson (2021): "I only teach uh or write out of New American Standard or the New King James." The BSSM graduate (2012–2015): "Bill for sure would preach from them." ~6–9 years apart; "teach or write" may exclude platform preaching; hers is a classroom impression, not a cited sermon. **Not filed as a caught lie.** What survives: the qualification stayed private while the endorsement went public. - **Cross-source convergence (unplanned).** Three of the six interlock without being about each other. Johnson deploys the Pharisee frame against scholarly critics; [[2026-07-16-remnant-radio-continuationists-cessationists|The Remnant Radio — Why Continuationists and Cessationists Keep Talking Past Each Other]] — two continuationists, sympathetic to his stream — independently traces that exact reflex to the 1904 Azusa Street class divide and names it an inherited defect. And [[2026-07-16-off-code-lecrae-piper-confession|Off Code — Reacting to Lecrae's John Piper Confession]] is a live instance of the "judge by the worst, not the best" mechanism that same Remnant Radio episode diagnoses. The critique of Johnson is available from *inside* the charismatic stream, which is the strongest form it can take. - **Concept/entity candidates strengthened (held for a directed pass, per envelope):** **The Remnant Radio / Joshua Lewis** entity is now at **4 sources** — past threshold since 07-10 and the longest-standing deferral in this list; **Destiny Image** has a third independent line; **Dusty May Taylor** (BSSM alumni, admins the unofficial alumni group) is a new entity candidate; **Monique Duson / Kevin Briggins / Center for Biblical Unity**, **Jonathan Allen Wright**, **Lecrae**, and **John Piper** are new candidates. **New concept candidate — the attendance-as-health-variable confound** (the same metric that predicts flourishing in a healthy congregation predicts harm in a coercive one) from the Wired Word lesson. No new entity/concept pages created. - **New coverage gaps named.** (1) **No Bethel institutional response** exists in the wiki — every institutional claim (alumni-group rejections, bookstore reversal, "eerie silence") is one-sided; its absence may itself be a finding, but "we could not find it" ≠ "it does not exist." (2) **The Johnson endorsement** ("the best thing to happen to Bible translations") is load-bearing in two places and sourced only secondhand. (3) **No primary Lecrae source** — filing his position from his critics' clips would repeat the exact error the Remnant Radio source diagnoses. (4) CCM history **parts 1–2** not ingested. - **Skipped / off-domain (24h window):** two title-plausible near-misses caught in triage — **"Don't Ignore Your SOUL.md With Erik Hanchett"** (a tech podcast about the `SOUL.md` file convention) and **"I Need You to Hear Me Out"** (Claude Code workflows and Codex system prompts). Also the WordPress/tech Readwise batch (WordPress 7.1 Beta/persistent toolbar, WooCommerce workflow, MCP 7-28, plugin-submission review, SSH-keys/AI security, RAG/fine-tuning, LinkedIn content, Zombie Companies, data-driven product decisions, project-based learning, Anthropic research report), all Tweets (GPT-5.6 in Codex, agents horizon, Bret Taylor, Eric Pvncher), two meeting notes (pivoting-webinars, rivet-workshop), and all Loop Reports. **raw/** empty; **Bible/** and **Religious Research/** unchanged (0 in window). - **Automation note (unattended run):** the ingest workflow (CLAUDE.md step 2) normally pauses for Courtney's confirmation before writing pages. This is a scheduled run with no human present, so per the scheduled-task rule I proceeded autonomously on the 6 in-window on-domain sources and recorded the choices here — consistent with every prior automated cycle. Scope held to the established envelope: **source pages + entity/concept citations + index + log only.** All new entity and concept pages held for a directed pass. **New this cycle (2026-07-16 — automated):** - **1 source page expanded + 2 concept updates.** No new files. The [[2026-07-10-counterfeit-kingdom-pivec-geivett|Counterfeit Kingdom — Holly Pivec & R. Douglas Geivett]] Readwise Books highlight set was re-synced 2026-07-15 (7 → 18 highlights); the new 11-passage cluster (Locations 1295–1414) is a second argument spine the 07-11 ingest never saw — apostolic authority as a governing office, not just prophecy-testing. Expanded the source page (Key Claims 8–13 + a Governance Cluster section) and added cited passages to [[Apostolic Authority]] (the "Dean" coercive-direction testimony, Location 1304; "alignment = submission," Location 1414) and [[Five-Fold Ministry]] (the Ephesians 4:11 "no offices, only elders and deacons" rebuttal, Locations 1375/1394/1402). - **Re-sync detection lesson.** The candidate was a same-path file whose mtime moved on a Readwise re-sync — the kind of touch prior cycles routinely skip as noise. It was real content this time because a highlight-count diff (7 → 18) against the existing source page's own "seven passages" caution flagged new material. Worth a standing check: for already-ingested Readwise sources, diff highlight count before dismissing an mtime bump. - **Concept/entity candidates strengthened (held for a directed pass, per envelope):** **spiritual abuse / BITE-model behavior control** now has a clean first-person specimen (the Dean couple could not move, change jobs, have children, or discipline their children without a prophet's sign-off); the [[Spiritual Abuse]] page could carry it directly in a directed session. No new pages created this cycle. - **Skipped / off-domain (24h window):** the WordPress/tech Readwise batch (CloudLinux/AutopilotWP, WordCamp US 2026, WordPress Apple TV app, Zombie Companies, Enterprise AI, "CEO Pleads With AI Industry"), the Open Source Governance + WordPress Hosting Security MOCs, two meeting notes (discord-community-strategy, youtube-channel-growth), and all Loop Reports (`_dashboard`, ci-triage, elestio-uptime, knowledge-hub-watch, recent-sources-log). **raw/** empty (assets/ only). Today's lint (`[[Lint 2026-07-16]]`, 275 pages / 685 issues) was produced by the separate wiki-nightly-promote loop at 06:53 — the count is the known meta-file false-positive class (log.md + Lint pages enumerate the forbidden wordlist). - **Automation note (unattended run):** the ingest workflow normally pauses for Courtney's confirmation before writing pages. This is a scheduled run with no human present, so per the scheduled-task rule I proceeded autonomously and recorded the choices here. Scope held to the established envelope: **source-page expansion + existing concept-page citations + index + log only.** No new entity/concept pages. **New this cycle (2026-07-14 — automated):** - **4 new source pages + 2 updates.** New: [[2026-07-14-pivec-nar-distraction-false-gospel|Holly Pivec — Are Your Church's Teachings Distracting You From Jesus?]], [[2026-07-14-mcclellan-jesus-in-the-old-testament|Dan McClellan — \"Jesus in the Old Testament Is Beyond Dispute\]], [[2026-07-14-mcclellan-women-pastors-heresy|Dan McClellan — \"Women Pastors Always Preach Heresy?\]], [[2026-07-14-remnant-radio-cracking-the-time-code|The Remnant Radio — Exposing \"Cracking the Time Code\" (Candice Smithyman)]]. Updated: [[Dan McClellan]] (10th + 11th sources; two new position bullets — retrojective messianic prophecy, and the non-univocality/pseudepigraphy case for women's ordination), [[Holly Pivec]] (5th source; attention-capture bullet + the dominion gospel-completion statement). - **⚠️ Prosperity gospel / word of faith — the pre-registered trigger has fired.** The 07-12 cycle held this candidate with the explicit note that "a dedicated source would tip a standalone page." [[2026-07-14-remnant-radio-cracking-the-time-code|The Remnant Radio — Exposing \"Cracking the Time Code\" (Candice Smithyman)]] **is** that source: a full-length treatment of word-of-faith mechanics (faith-as-income, perception-nullifies-blessing, death-as-optional) with the 1980s lineage named, joining the Gupta/Bonhoeffer critique and the McClellan wealth-etiology jab. Held **only** because concept creation is a directed-pass decision — this is the top recommendation for the next directed session. - **Cross-tradition pattern identified — word study as authority move.** Three sources from three traditions now converge on one mechanism: untestable language claims used to manufacture authority over readers who cannot check them. [[2026-07-14-remnant-radio-cracking-the-time-code|The Remnant Radio — Exposing \"Cracking the Time Code\" (Candice Smithyman)]] (continuationist insider, on invented Hebrew/Greek), [[The Passion Translation]] (Simmons's unsupported Aramaic renderings), and [[2026-07-14-mcclellan-jesus-in-the-old-testament|Dan McClellan — \"Jesus in the Old Testament Is Beyond Dispute\]] (secular academic, on Psalm 22 / Isaiah 7:14 mistranslations offered as evidence for the readings that produced them). Would sit naturally beside [[NAR Fallacy Taxonomy]]. Strong new concept candidate. - **Pseudepigraphy concept candidate — now at threshold.** Four-plus sources, stable structure, load-bearing in multiple arguments: historical-Paul-vs-pseudo-Paul on celibacy/childbearing, authentic-Paul-over-Ephesians-5 on submission ([[2026-07-05-data-over-dogma-monte-mader-purity-culture|Inside Purity Culture and Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]]), and now the whole case for women's ordination. Nothing currently covers it. - **Feminist hermeneutics / erased women — advanced 1 → 3 data points.** Sarah's non-agency and Rebekah's silence (07-12) now joined by **Junia** — a woman apostle in an authentic letter, overruled by a forgery. Pairs with [[2026-06-10-mcclellan-feminism-satanic-roots|Dan McClellan — Responding to 'Feminism Has Satanic Roots]]. May now be better-supported than the source-criticism candidate. - **New candidates flagged:** **supersessionism** (the 2 Cor 3 "veil over their hearts" rhetoric against Jewish readers; a DEIB gap, with a second data point in the America-as-Israel material); **messianic prophecy / typology / retrojective hermeneutics** (the strongest single-source case the wiki has for a new concept node — it names a *method* used across NAR, evangelical, and word-of-faith material); **gnosticism as a recurring import** (two independent sources — Lewis's "earth suit" and [[2026-07-02-mcclellan-image-of-god-divine-council|Dan McClellan — What Does It Mean to Be Created \"In God's Image\"?]] on "flesh is inherently sinful" as middle-Platonic/Gnostic); **attention as a spiritual-abuse mechanism** (distinct from the coercion/shame mechanisms under [[Religious Trauma]]). - **New entity candidates:** [[Candice Smithyman]] (apostolic-prophetic minister; Dream Mentors International; Glory Road TV; *Your Path to Destiny* on the It's Supernatural network) and **Destiny Image** (publisher) — the latter notable because [[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]] already names the "Destiny Image publisher network" as an NAR structure, so the Smithyman book independently corroborates a claim the wiki filed months ago. [[Joshua Lewis]] / [[The Remnant Radio]] remain past threshold at 3 sources (flagged since 07-10). - **Two independent critics, one diagnosis.** Pivec's Eden charge ("you can be like God" via secret knowledge + magical power) and Lewis's gnostic-adjacent reading reach the same conclusion from opposite vantages — cessationist-leaning outsider vs. continuationist insider — without shared vocabulary. Worth a line in any future prosperity-gospel or gnosticism page. - **Vault-hygiene finding (outside this wiki, reported not fixed):** `3. Resources/Readwise/Full Document Contents/Articles/CLAUDE.md` is a Readwise capture of a claude.ai chat page, but its filename causes Claude Code to auto-load it as *project instructions* in any session touching that directory. Content is inert, but it injects a large fake instruction block into context. Recommend renaming. Also: the Document Notes block on the Smithyman capture garbles the very words the video is about (*yada*→"Eddu" and mislabeled Greek, *regel*→"Regal", *chronos*→"Kronos"); the transcript is correct and this wiki follows it. - **Skipped / off-domain:** all other 24h-window files — Loop Reports (`_dashboard`, airo-pipeline, ci-triage, elestio-uptime, knowledge-hub-watch, recent-sources-log, staging-drift, synthesis-pass), Literature/Permanent notes and MOCs on WordPress/DX/open-source governance, and the tech/AI Readwise items (Claude for Teachers, Cowork, CodeRabbit, Astro, GPT-5.6, State of Open Source AI, WCAG/WordPress, DesignOps, agency pricing, USB-C cable tools, TWiW #380) + tweets. **raw/** empty (assets/ only) — no new drops. - **Automation note (unattended run):** the ingest workflow normally pauses for Courtney's confirmation before writing pages. This is a scheduled run with no human present, so per the scheduled-task rule I proceeded autonomously on the 4 in-window on-domain sources and recorded the choices here. Consistent with every prior automated cycle: **source pages + entity updates only**; all new entity/concept pages held for a directed pass. **New this cycle (2026-07-12 — automated):** - **1 new source page + 1 update.** New: [[2026-07-12-data-over-dogma-wife-sister-deception|Data Over Dogma — When God Told Abraham to Lie (the wife-sister doublets)]] (source). Updated: [[Dan McClellan]] (11th source + "Genesis is stitched from independent traditions" position). - **Source-criticism / documentary-hypothesis concept candidate advanced** — the wife-sister doublets join the [[2026-06-29-data-over-dogma-myth-of-12-tribes|Data Over Dogma — The Myth of the 12 Tribes of Israel]] construction argument and the [[2026-07-01-chapters-and-verses-versification-history|Chapters and Verses Are Reading the Bible for You (Data Over Dogma)]] hermeneutics thread; the wiki now has enough for a dedicated **source criticism** concept node (Genesis seams: divine-name switches, name changes, anachronism, doublets). Arguably at threshold — held for a directed pass, folded into [[Dan McClellan]] + [[Deconstruction]] until then. - **New candidate — feminist hermeneutics / erased women** — Sarah's non-agency in the wife-sister stories (and Rebekah's silence) is the first data point; pairs with the earlier "biblical marriage as property" ([[2026-07-05-data-over-dogma-monte-mader-purity-culture|Inside Purity Culture and Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]]) and purity-culture material. Held below threshold. - **Prosperity-gospel candidate** — gains a second data point (Beecher/McClellan's "that's the prosperity gospel" reading of the wealth-etiology, alongside the 07-05 Gupta/Bonhoeffer critique). Still held; a dedicated source would tip a standalone page. - **Deferred in-window (lectionary prep — standing rule):** UCC Cast "Seeds & Ways" **"You Shall Spread" — Eighth Sunday Year A Pentecost** (Rev. Dr. Cheryl A. Lindsay; Jacob-at-Bethel/Genesis 28, covenant blessing, Jacob-as-avoidant-runner). Generic Year-A preaching prep, not tied to a dated St. John's service (today's 07-12 service was the lay-led Hymn Sing with no sermon) → deferred per the standing rule. **The "Seeds & Ways" cluster is now large (~9 deferred episodes across 06-24 → 07-12).** Recommend a directed decision on one **combined UCC Cast lectionary source page**; escalated from "if the cluster builds" to "the cluster has built." - **Skipped:** Code Switch "Whose rights just changed? Our SCOTUS debrief" (NPR; immigration/asylum/TPS law, no faith angle → off-domain). All other 24h-window files were off-domain (Loop Reports, Plugin Health, Skill Gaps, tech/AI articles + tweets) or Readwise re-sync mtime touches. **New this cycle (2026-07-11 — automated):** - **3 new source pages + 3 updates.** New: [[2026-07-10-counterfeit-kingdom-pivec-geivett|Counterfeit Kingdom — Holly Pivec & R. Douglas Geivett]], [[2026-07-10-uchimura-prophetic-nationalism|Nationalism Can Be Prophetic — Uchimura Kanzō (Kazusa Okaya)]], [[2026-05-24-unbelief-evangelical-code-words-steele|Evangelical Code Words — Jeremy Steele (Unbelief podcast)]]. Updated: [[Holly Pivec]] (Counterfeit Kingdom anchor source + prophecy-testing/New-Age bullet), [[Christian Nationalism]] (rhetorical/dog-whistle vantage + Uchimura comparative "prophetic nationalism" section — now six vantages), [[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] (congregational rhetorical-formation layer: Peretti/armor-of-God + "rebuke" migration). - **[[Christian Nationalism]] advanced (again)** — two new vantages: a *rhetorical/dog-whistle* mechanism (Steele) and a *comparative non-Western* case (Uchimura's "prophetic nationalism"), which uniquely names the progressive mirror-idolatry (critique-as-contempt) guarding the Whitaker constructive counter from curdling. The book-length monograph (Du Mez / Taylor / Hobbs) remains the open goal. - **[[Holly Pivec]] flagship-book gap closed** — *Counterfeit Kingdom* was cited across the wiki (e.g. [[NAR Fallacy Taxonomy]]) but never a source page; it now anchors the entity and supplies the affirmative prophecy-testing rubric the [[Fallible Prophecy]] page critiques the absence of. - **[[Spiritual Warfare Theology]] stub advanced** — gained a non-charismatic-insider rhetorical-formation layer (still a stub overall; primary sources Wagner/Wink/IHOPKC remain outstanding). - **Concept candidates flagged:** an *Evangelical Code Words / religious dog-whistles* concept page (Steele episode + the vault permanent note + prior Christian-nationalism rhetoric across the corpus — arguably at threshold; held for a directed pass); a *prophecy-testing rubric* concept node (Counterfeit Kingdom's three tests could anchor a standalone page beside [[Fallible Prophecy]]). Entity candidate: [[Jeremy Steele]] / *Unbelief* (2 sources now — this + [[2026-07-05-unbelief-coons-faith-and-politics|Sen. Chris Coons on Christian Nationalism and Faith in Politics (Unbelief)]] + [[2026-07-05-unbelief-pastor-predator-deconstruction|Unbelief — When the Pastor Was the Predator (Kate Johnson)]] are the same show → threshold met, held for a directed *Unbelief* entity pass). - **Skipped / triaged out:** the [[2026-07-12]] St. John's UCC service note — a lay-led "Hymn Sing Sunday" with **no sermon** (Rev. Saxton on vacation); 14 hymns, all traditional/public-domain (It Is Well, Blessed Assurance, When I Survey, Victory in Jesus, etc.), none with NAR/Bethel/Hillsong network flags → passes the existing worship-vetting rubric with nothing new to capture; no page warranted. *Is Bethel Church Past the Point of No Return?* and the Azusa/Parhamite Ep. 650 — both already ingested in the 07-10 cycle; their 24h mtime is a Readwise re-sync touch, not new content. **New this cycle (2026-07-10 — automated):** - **4 new source pages + 4 updates.** New: [[2026-07-09-leaving-the-message-azusa-parhamite-roots-ep650|Azusa History Overturned: The Parhamite Roots — Leaving the Message Ep. 650]], [[2026-07-09-remnant-radio-bethel-point-of-no-return|Is Bethel Church Past the Point of No Return? — The Remnant Radio]], [[2026-07-09-wired-word-empire-state-boldness-risk|Wired Word — Couple Climbs Empire State Building (Week of July 12, 2026)]], [[2026-07-09-tim-whitaker-dissent-prophetic-tradition|Discouraged by the State America Is In? — Tim Whitaker]]. Updated: [[Charles Fox Parham]] (Apostolic-Faith→NAR name-line + 1906 magazine core), [[Pentecostalism]] (Parham-first vs. Seymour-first origin note), [[Bethel Church]] (2026-07 retaliation/NDA + continuationist "point of no return" read; also wired in the previously-orphaned [[2026-07-07-bethel-layoffs-ndas-tpt-censorship|Bethel Layoffs, Non-Disparagement Agreements, and TPT Censorship — Wake Up and Win Podcast]] as a source), [[Christian Nationalism]] (constructive prophetic-dissent vantage — now four vantages). - **[[Christian Nationalism]] advanced** — gained a fourth vantage: a *constructive* counter (Whitaker's prophetic-dissent reclamation) alongside the three existing critique vantages. The book-length monograph (Du Mez / Taylor / Hobbs) is still the open goal. - **[[Charles Fox Parham]] / [[Pentecostalism]] origins-critique** — the Parham-first genealogy now has a primary-document anchor (the 1906 *Apostolic Faith*). Open thread: locate the actual Seymour statement Collins cites (load-bearing for the "coverup" claim) before hardening it in any analysis page. - **Bethel orphan fixed** — the 2026-07-07 Wake Up and Win layoffs/NDA source page existed but was never wired into the [[Bethel Church]] entity or index; both now reference it, and the Remnant Radio source corroborates it from the continuationist angle. - **Entity candidates (single-source, held below threshold):** [[Tim Whitaker]] + [[The New Evangelicals]] (post-evangelical anti-Christian-nationalism voice/org; TNE podcast already sourced via [[2026-06-15-tamice-spencer-helms-better-logics|Discovering Better Logics in a Binary World — Dr. Tamice Spencer-Helms (TNE Podcasts)]] → arguably at threshold, held for a directed pass), [[Joshua Lewis]] / [[The Remnant Radio]] (continuationist discernment podcast, now 2 sources — [[2026-06-18-remnant-radio-reformers-spiritual-gifts|Did Protestant Reformers Believe in Spiritual Gifts? (The Remnant Radio)]] + this — a directed pass could build it). - **Concept candidates flagged:** a *Christian boldness / faithful risk* discipleship node (Wired Word 07/12 boldness-vs-timidity + Peter-on-water / talents readings) and a *Liberation Theology* concept page (Whitaker's "faith of love and liberation," MLK "white moderate," the prophetic-tradition lineage) — each held for a second dedicated source. - **Skipped / already-covered:** *LEAKED: Bethel Firing 50 People* (Wake Up and Win) — already ingested as [[2026-07-07-bethel-layoffs-ndas-tpt-censorship|Bethel Layoffs, Non-Disparagement Agreements, and TPT Censorship — Wake Up and Win Podcast]]; its 07-09 mtime is a Readwise re-sync touch. The *guru model of modern prophecy* (Bob Scott) and *Sodom & Gomorrah* (McClellan) literature notes — both already ingested ([[Bob Scott — The Guru Model Behind Modern Prophecy (Ep. 630)]], [[Dan McClellan — Sodom & Gomorrah Is Not About Homosexuality]]); 24h mtime is a re-sync touch. Ecclesiastes MSG/AMPC translation files + Bible Study Ecclesiastes SVGs — Bible-corpus texts and study visuals, not external sources to ingest. **New this cycle (2026-07-06 — automated):** - **5 new pages + 3 updates.** New: [[2026-07-05-st-johns-ucc-esther-moment-like-this|St. John's UCC — Esther: A Moment Like This]] (source), [[2026-07-05-unbelief-pastor-predator-deconstruction|Unbelief — When the Pastor Was the Predator (Kate Johnson)]] (source), [[2026-07-05-holy-post-725-americas-story-gupta-paul|Holy Post 725 — America's Story + Nijay Gupta on Paul]] (source), [[2026-07-05-holy-post-727-mckenzie-sexual-revolution-250|Holy Post 727 — Robert Tracy McKenzie on America at 250]] (source), [[Purity Culture]] (concept). Updated: [[Caroline Saxton]] (July 5 Esther sermon), [[Christian Nationalism]] (moderate-evangelical + mainline critique layer; stub callout re-scoped), [[Eschatology]] (Gupta restoration-vs-escape section). - ~~**Purity Culture concept candidate**~~ — **closed 2026-07-06.** The second dedicated source landed (Kate Johnson's *Unbelief* testimony) alongside the 07-05 Mader episode → threshold met, `concepts/purity-culture.md` built (commodification metaphors, gendered double standard, consent erasure, DARVO adjacency). Open question: still needs a sympathetic-insider reckoning + constructive alternatives. - **[[Christian Nationalism]] advanced** — the long-open "primary source gap" is no longer a bare stub: a three-vantage critique layer now exists (moderate-evangelical Holy Post 725/727 + mainline Coons/Wired Word + discernment/ex-insider WBHR/DoD). Book-length monograph (Du Mez / Taylor / Hobbs) still the goal. - **Entity candidates (single-source, held below threshold):** [[Nijay Gupta]] (NT scholar; *Paul for the World*; restoration eschatology), [[Robert Tracy McKenzie]] (Wheaton historian; Christian-nationalism critique), [[Kate Johnson]] (deconstruction/clergy-abuse testimony), [[Kaitlyn Schiess]] (Holy Post co-host; political theology). Build on a second source. - **Prosperity-gospel + Christian-masculinity/manosphere concept candidates** — each now has a data point (Gupta's Bonhoeffer critique; the Holy Post "pagan masculinity" segment). Held for a second source. - **Deferred in-window (lectionary prep):** UCC Cast "Seeds & Ways" Year-A episodes ("It Shall Be Provided" 5th Sun; "And God Heard" 4th Sun) and Working Preacher "Sermon Brainwave" 1091 / 1093 / 1094. Generic lectionary/preaching prep, not tied to a dated St. John's service — deferred per the standing rule. - **Skipped:** *Sacred Yes* (Jen Hatmaker solo) — a midlife rest/boundaries/"unproductive joy" self-care episode with only light spiritual framing; below the theology threshold. Logged as a [[Jen Hatmaker]] entity candidate if a substantive-theology episode lands. ATG 288 "The First Key to Bravery" (Jon Acuff) — secular goals/productivity, off-domain. *United and Uniting* — already ingested (Gunnemann UCC-history thread, 7 prior log mentions); the `date: 2026-07-05` is a Readwise re-sync touch, not new. **New this cycle (2026-07-05 — automated):** - **3 new pages + 2 updates.** New: [[2026-07-05-data-over-dogma-monte-mader-purity-culture|Inside Purity Culture and Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]] (source), [[2026-07-05-unbelief-coons-faith-and-politics|Sen. Chris Coons on Christian Nationalism and Faith in Politics (Unbelief)]] (source), [[Monte Mader]] (entity). Updated: [[Dan McClellan]] (10th source + marriage-as-commodity position), [[Open and Affirming]] (2nd source added; open question re-scoped to the exegetical debate). - ~~**[[Monte Mader]] dead-link stub**~~ — **closed 2026-07-05.** Entity page built now that a second primary source has landed (the purity-culture episode). Two *Data Over Dogma* sources; ex-member testimony node for [[Christian Nationalism]] and [[Deconstruction]]. - **[[Open and Affirming]] second source** — the standing "second-source upgrade" carry-over is now advanced: Coons supplies a cross-mainline witness to lived ONA practice. The page's open question is re-scoped — it still needs a source that engages the exegesis (clobber passages, marriage theology, a "welcoming but not affirming" primary read). - **Purity Culture concept candidate** — first dedicated source (the Mader purity-culture episode). Held below the two-source threshold; a second (a purity-culture memoir or the "I Kissed Dating Goodbye" reckoning) tips a standalone `concepts/purity-culture.md`. - **Jerry Falwell / Moral Majority node** — now a two-mention candidate (Coons's "religion is about controlling sexuality" root + the 06-22 Data Over Dogma Falwell/Weyrich wedge-issue history). Entity/concept stub on a directed pass. - **[[Chris Coons]] stub** — mainline Democratic senator; faith-and-politics reflection group; expand if a second source lands. - **Deferred in-window (lectionary prep):** three UCC Cast "Seeds & Ways" Year-A Pentecost episodes ("Shall I Be Fruitful," "Granted Prayer," "Journeyed on by Stages") and Working Preacher "Sermon Brainwave" 1089/1090. Generic lectionary/preaching prep, not tied to a dated St. John's UCC service — deferred per the standing rule (cf. Sermon Brainwave 1080–1088). If a cluster of UCC Cast episodes builds, consider one combined lectionary source page. - **Skipped:** Holy Post 723 (real `episode_publish_date` 2026-06-03, out of window; `last_snip_date` re-sync touch; Pope Leo already covered). "Sermon sketch" inbox note (pipeline test file `inq-live-test.md` carrying Courtney's own Ecclesiastes sketch — her own study output, not an external source). **Closed this cycle (2026-05-27 — automated):** - ~~**[[Theodicy]]**~~ — **closed 2026-05-27.** Full concept page: Epicurus trilemma, Hume restatement, logical/evidential/pastoral variants, free will defense, soul-making, protest/lament (Job, Wiesel), open theism, process theology, lament without resolution (McLaren/Bessey). NAR implicit theodicy (SLSW as theodicy: demonic territorial control). Caroline Saxton's lament-and-presence pneumatology (April 26 + May 24 sermons). Theodicy as deconstruction entry point. Four vault sources. Highest-priority dead link since 2026-04-27; resolved after 18 lint cycles. - ~~**[[Spiritual Warfare Theology]]**~~ — **closed 2026-05-27 (stub).** Concept stub: full evangelical-to-NAR spectrum; SLSW doctrine (Wagner, territorial spirits, spiritual mapping); harm assessment; Walter Wink mainline contrast (powers = institutional spirituality of human systems); IHOPKC connection. Resolves dead link introduced in prior cycle. Primary sources (Wagner, Wink) still needed. - ~~**NL442 post-service gap**~~ — **closed 2026-05-27.** `sources/2026-05-17-st-johns-ucc-christ-hymn.md` updated with Post-Service Update section. Hymn Sing Sunday confirmed; 13 congregation-selected hymns documented with copyright status and worship-team notes; Courtney on worship team confirmed; Habitat Q&A happened. Page was pending since 2026-05-11. - ~~**Life After Doom source page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-27.** `readwise-life-after-doom-mclaren.md` written. All prerequisite source material for `[[Deconstruction]]` concept page now in wiki. **New this cycle (2026-05-27):** - **[[Brian McLaren]] entity stub** — new dead link introduced by Life After Doom source page. Entity page needed: progressive Christianity founding voice; *Life After Doom* (2023); Convergence Music Project co-founder. 1 reference currently; will grow as Deconstruction page is drafted. - **[[Deconstruction]] concept page** — now has two primary sources fully ingested: [[readwise-life-after-doom-mclaren|Life After Doom — Brian D. McLaren (Readwise)]] and [[readwise-field-notes-for-the-wilderness-bessey|Field Notes for the Wilderness (Sarah Bessey)]]. Also grounded in Caroline Saxton's preaching (theodicy thread, May 24 lament-and-presence framing). Ready to draft. **High priority.** - **13 Hymn Sing hymns (May 17)** — 13 congregation-selected hymns documented in NL442 source page but not yet processed through the formal St. John's UCC 4-tier rubric. Most are public-domain; no NAR flags detected. Formal assessment flagged for a dedicated worship-music session. - **May 31 Trinity Sunday + Habitat for Humanity vote** — congregational vote on property/Habitat development proposal. Watch for `Sermon Notes/2026-05-31.md` and `Sermon Notes/2026-06-07.md` after service. First fully active ecclesial-discernment thread. **New this cycle (2026-06-09 — automated, large batch after ~12-day gap):** - **8 new pages** from a heavy Readwise sync dominated by [[The Passion Translation]]: [[The Passion Translation]] (concept, flagship), [[brian-simmons|Brian Simmons]] (entity), [[Mike Winger]] (entity), [[Charles Fox Parham]] (entity), and 4 source pages ([[readwise-passion-translation-critique-cluster|Readwise — Passion Translation Critique Cluster]], [[readwise-pentecostal-nar-origins-critique-cluster|Readwise — Pentecostal / NAR Origins Critique Cluster]], [[readwise-monte-mader-christian-nationalism|Readwise — Inside Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]], [[2026-06-07 St John's UCC — Ruth: Loss and Loyalty]]). - **Habitat-thread correction** — the 2026-06-07 sermon does NOT continue the Habitat/Trinity thread (no Habitat content; guest preacher; Ruth series). The Habitat vote likely sits in `Sermon Notes/2026-05-31.md`, which is **not yet ingested** — priority next cycle. - **New dead-link stubs opened (7):** [[Holly Pivec]] (NARWatch; "the NAR Bible"), [[William J. Seymour]] (Azusa Street leader), [[John Alexander Dowie]] (Zion City), [[Azusa Street Revival]] (movement/event), [[Monte Mader]] (ex-CN educator), [[Dan McClellan]] (Data Over Dogma; optional), [[Deconstruction]] (still unwritten; referenced again by the Mader source). - **Christian Nationalism promote** — [[Christian Nationalism]] is still a stub; [[readwise-monte-mader-christian-nationalism|Readwise — Inside Christian Nationalism with Monte Mader (Data Over Dogma)]] is now its first primary source. Ready to expand (insider-formation account + NAR/Dominionism overlap). **High priority.** - **Pages to update (deferred to a Courtney-directed session):** [[New Apostolic Reformation]] (add TPT in-house-Bible function), [[Bethel Church]] (TPT two-tier text practice + bookstore), [[Pentecostalism]] and [[Latter Rain]] (origins-critique cluster, with source caution). - **Source caution logged** — the Azusa/NAR-origins cluster is polemical (William Branham research orbit). Genealogical and biographical claims (Parham's record, Dowie finances) need confirmation against academic Pentecostal historiography before entering analysis pages. **New this cycle (2026-06-11 — automated maintenance, McClellan/NAR atom batch):** - **4 new pages** from three theology atoms created today in `Literature Notes/`: [[Bob Scott — The Guru Model Behind Modern Prophecy (Ep. 630)]] (source) + [[Bob Scott]] (entity), [[Dan McClellan — Sodom & Gomorrah Is Not About Homosexuality]] (source), [[The Hidden History Behind Calvary Chapel and the Vineyard — Cover-Up Culture]] (source). [[Dan McClellan]] entity updated with the anachronism position. - **Structural-theory thread.** The Bob Scott "guru model" page gives the wiki an explicit mechanism page to pair with its NAR case studies — single-mediator authority + media-conferred rank + competitive escalation, a mirror of [[Apostolic Authority]]. - **New dead-link stubs opened (4):** [[Lonnie Frisbee]], [[Paul Cain]], [[John Wimber]], [[Chuck Smith]] — Calvary Chapel / Vineyard lineage; [[Paul Cain]] also links the Vineyard orbit to [[Mike Bickle]] / IHOPKC. - **Source caution logged** — the Calvary Chapel / Vineyard piece is investigative/polemical; biographical claims recorded as stated, confirm before analysis-page use. **Closed this cycle (2026-05-26 — manual: Bethel/Welton entity stubs):** - ~~**9 entity stubs from the Bethel/Welton ingest**~~ — **closed 2026-05-26.** Full entity pages created for [[Jonathan Welton]], [[danny-silk|Danny Silk]], [[Ben Armstrong]], [[Shawn Bolz]], [[Randy Clark]], [[Leif Hetland]], [[Harold Eberle]], [[Joel Richardson]], and [[Michael Brown]]. All grounded in [[2026-05-19-bethels-book-platformed-a-wolf-video|Bethel's Book Platformed a Wolf and Silenced His Victims (YouTube exposé video)]]; cross-linked; added to People & Authors. Resolves 9 dead-link clusters (incl. [[Shawn Bolz]], the most-referenced at 11 links). No new dead links introduced. - Follow-ups opened: [[Harold Eberle]] restoration-board identification needs confirmation from named board members; [[Michael Brown]] controversy and [[Randy Clark]] / Global Awakening + Toronto Blessing want dedicated primary sources. **Closed this cycle (2026-05-26 — automated):** - ~~**[[Kelly Latimore]]**~~ — **closed 2026-05-24.** Full entity page created: American Catholic iconographer; Byzantine influence; incarnational diversity theology; Marian inclusion in Pentecost icon; disability representation; UCC use at St. John's. Dead link in 2026-05-24 Pentecost source page resolved. - **[[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]]** — indexed. Pivec & Geivett evangelical-cessationist NAR critique. Source page created 2026-05-24. - **[[research-world-harvest-outreach-nar|The New Apostolic Reformation and World Harvest Outreach: A Comprehensive Analysis]]** — indexed (partial ingest). World Harvest Outreach Chambersburg NAR research. Full ingest requires dedicated session. **New this cycle (2026-05-26 — automated):** - **[[Spiritual Warfare Theology]]** — new dead link introduced by `readwise-nar-pivec-geivett.md`. Referenced in Pivec/Geivett strategic-level spiritual warfare section. Concept stub needed: NAR territorial-spirit model, dominionist application, mainline structural-sin contrast. Builds on [[Dominionism]] entry already in wiki. - **NL443 Pentecost sermon notes** — vault not mounted this cycle. Sermon occurred May 24, 2026. Check next session for `Sermon Notes/2026-05-24.md` content and 13-category rubric opportunity. - **World Harvest Outreach full ingest** — 60KB research document partially read. Full ingest (entity page, network documentation, local NAR case study) requires dedicated session with Courtney. - **[[readwise-nar-pivec-geivett|A New Apostolic Reformation? A Biblical Response to a Worldwide Movement]] pages to update** — source page identifies 3 existing wiki pages to update with Pivec/Geivett content: [[New Apostolic Reformation]] (working definition, Passion Translation, Destiny Image, 369M figure, AG divergence), [[Apostolic Authority]] (submission logic quote, financial structure, accountability gap), [[Five-Fold Ministry]] (cessationist elder-appointment argument from Titus 1:5 / 1 Pet 5:1–3). Requires Courtney direction. **New this cycle (2026-05-23):** - ~~**[[Kelly Latimore]]**~~ — **closed 2026-05-24.** See above. - **Johannine vs. Lukan Pentecost** — concept page candidate; two distinct biblical pneumatologies within the canon; neither maps to NAR/charismatic Pentecost; important comparison for the NAR-critique framework. Would close a conceptual gap. - **Joel 2:28-32 hermeneutics** — concept page candidate; the most contested Pentecost text: NAR uses it for prophetic office restoration; mainline uses it for inclusive leadership and anti-hierarchical ecclesiology. Ready to draft from the May 24 source page alone. - **NL443 Pentecost sermon** — actual sermon content will appear in `Sermon Notes/2026-05-24.md` after the service (May 24, 2026). The source page ingested today covers the bulletin/pre-service scaffold; check next cycle for sermon notes fill-in and 13-category rubric opportunity. **Ongoing:** - ~~**Koinonia concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-18.** See above. - ~~**Theodicy concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-27.** Full concept page written. See above. - Paula Gooder primary source for the "resurrection as rebellion" quote — need to locate - NAR vs. UCC theology of healing and the "transformed trauma" reading of John 20 — worth an analysis page - **NL442 sermon + rubric** — May 17, 2026 service. Prep stub created 2026-05-11. Sermon notes and 13-category rubric pending after May 17 service. - **NL444 13-category rubric** — Sermon notes ingested 2026-05-11; full rubric scoring (65-point scale) still pending YouTube recording. - **Habitat for Humanity thread** — congregational Q&A May 17; vote May 31. Track ecclesial discernment on property use. First appearance in sermon record. - **[[Deconstruction]] concept page** — now has two fully-ingested source pages: [[readwise-field-notes-for-the-wilderness-bessey|Field Notes for the Wilderness (Sarah Bessey)]] and [[readwise-life-after-doom-mclaren|Life After Doom — Brian D. McLaren (Readwise)]]. Also grounded in Caroline Saxton's lament-and-presence pneumatology. **Ready to draft. High priority.** - ~~**Life After Doom** (McLaren) source page~~ — **closed 2026-05-27.** `readwise-life-after-doom-mclaren.md` written. 8 key arguments extracted; all key quotes captured. - **Cole Arthur Riley** — no entity page; minor scope for this wiki but relevant to DEIB and liturgy threads - Worship-team one-page screening checklist — possible future output, directly buildable from the Aniol + Modern Reformation + new Calvin/UMC source material now in the wiki - Assemblies of God 2025 position paper on modern-day prophets — primary doc, priority follow-up - Kris Vallotton primary text (*Basic Training for the Prophetic Ministry*) — priority NAR-side source - Wayne Grudem, *The Gift of Prophecy in the New Testament and Today* — academic framework in dispute - Kristin Kobes Du Mez / Matthew D. Taylor on NAR — already in Readwise/Books, not yet ingested (*The Violent Take It by Force*) - `1. Projects/Religious Research/World Harvest Outreach.md` — in vault, not yet ingested; primary-source NAR material - Sermon-notes backfill — pre-2026-04-12 sermons at St. John's UCC remain unanalyzed (2026-04-05, 2026-03-29, and earlier) - **Book review backfill reserve (flagged 2026-04-18)** — 8+ theology-relevant book reviews in `4. Archives/Book reviews/` (*A New Apostolic Reformation*, *Out of the Embers*, *What Would Jesus Deconstruct*, *Process Theology Guide*, *Theological Foundations of Worship*, *Revelation and Violence*, *When Heaven Invades Earth*, *Sacred Playgrounds*) — Courtney's own prior analysis - **NAR "prophetic calendar" vs. Christian liturgical calendar** (2026-04-19) — `Readwise/Books/A Prophetic Calendar` sits in-vault as a primary NAR-side source - ~~**Decisional conversion concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-06.** Full concept page: Finney's origins, NAR amplification, Caroline Saxton's "conversion as draft" framing across Acts sermons, *oikos* baptism, DEIB analysis. - ~~**The Inclusive Bible (Priests for Equality)**~~ — **closed 2026-04-30.** Full concept page written. - ~~**Musical sacramentality concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-05.** Full concept page written: Lim/Ruth/Ingalls/Hobbs; Reformed and progressive critiques; pastoral-exclusion implications. - ~~**Covenant Renewal Worship concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-05.** Full concept page written: Exodus 19–24 shape; five movements; presider-as-herald; convergence with mainline. - ~~**CCLI reporting and royalty flow concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-06.** Full concept page: license types, royalty mechanics, Top 100 data limitations, OneLicense, practical and theological implications for St. John's UCC. - ~~**Dominionism concept page**~~ — **closed 2026-05-04.** Full concept page written: Seven Mountain Mandate, Wagner, three-tradition critique, DEIB assessment. - **Primary NAR text ingests** — Cornwall *Let Us Praise* (1973), Zschech *Extravagant Worship* (2002), Johnson *When Heaven Invades Earth* (2003), Vallotton *Basic Training for the Prophetic Ministry* - **Just and Generous Worship Music podcast eps 2 (Ruth Bruxvoort Colligan) and 3 (Heidi Wilson)** — unread this cycle due to sandbox file-size constraints; flag for next cycle - **Cross-reference Roelofs's specific CCLI song evaluations** (new 2026-04-22) — pull the Calvin Institute vetting set and map against Worship Songs Evaluated - **UCC Open and Affirming Coalition worship resource deep-read** (new 2026-04-22) — source page references the Coalition's inclusive-language liturgy work but has not yet been pulled into a full ingest - **NAD Ministerial blended-worship practice article full text** (new 2026-04-22) — only the highlight-stub was surfaced this cycle; full article worth pulling for a Blended Worship concept expansion - **Scheduled cadence** — daily 24h scans plus a weekly "since last ingest" pass would better match Readwise batch-sync reality - **Closure liturgies as a Worship Songs Evaluated category** (new 2026-04-23) — add "transition / closure / memorial" bucket; seed with Ubi caritas, Micah 6:8 settings, Psalm 130 settings - **Denomination-level *telos* essay** (new 2026-04-23) — if congregations can finish well, can a denomination? Live question for UCC - **Friedman / Cloud / Steed as a pastoral-theology mini-canon** (new 2026-04-23) — the 04-23 Wired Word co-cites them; worth its own analysis or concept cluster - **Full ingest: *Afro-Christian Convention* (Yvonne Delk)** — only 2 Readwise highlights available; full book text needed for complete ingest. High priority given direct relevance to UCC identity, worship theology, and DEIB lens. - **Percel O. Alston** — UCC historian cited in Delk's book; worth a stub entity if additional sources can be located. ### Stub entities to expand - [[Bethel Music]] — separate brand-focused page distinct from [[Bethel Church]] - [[Jesus Culture]] — Bethel-adjacent brand - [[Frank Houston]] — Royal Commission material - [[Michael Horton]] — Modern Reformation founder - [[Mary Louise Bringle]] — PCUSA *Glory to God* chair, composer - [[Mark Miller]] — UCC composer, "Child of God," "I Choose Love" - [[Brian McLaren]] — progressive Christianity founding voice; *Life After Doom* (2023); post-colonial hermeneutics; entity stub needed (new dead link 2026-05-27) - [[Cameron Trimble]], [[Otis Moss III]] — CMP co-founders - [[Rachel Held Evans]], [[Pete Enns]], [[Diana Butler Bass]], [[Walter Brueggemann]] — progressive-Christianity anchor voices - [[Beth Allison Barr]], [[Kristin Kobes Du Mez]] — activist-historian voices - ~~[[Shawn Bolz]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-26.** Entity stub created: Bethel-orbit prophetic minister; *Unpunishable* foreword; words-of-knowledge; Fallible Prophecy example. - [[Upper Room Dallas]] — NAR-adjacent worship arm frequently co-producing with Maverick City - [[Medical Mission Sisters]] — Winter's order - ~~[[Christian Feminism Today]] (EEWC-CFT)~~ — **closed 2026-04-25.** Full entity page created. - ~~[[Bryan Sirchio]]~~ — **closed 2026-04-25.** Full entity page created. - ~~[[Brian Hehn]]~~ — **closed 2026-04-25.** Full entity page created. - [[Mary Elizabeth Johnson]] — new stub flagged 2026-04-26; appears in Singer and Song review; identity unclear (Medical Mission Sister or Winter collaborator?). - **The slave-girl in Acts 16:16–18** — womanist commentary thread opened 2026-04-27; Caroline named the textual gap; consult Mitzi Smith and Demetrius Williams before a future Acts 16 analysis page. - **Household baptism (*oikos*) analysis page** — opened 2026-04-27; Acts 10, 16, 18 pattern; relevant to sacramental theology. - **"God does not cause suffering / God is present in it" — theodicy analysis page** — opened 2026-04-27; NAR vs. Reformed vs. progressive-mainline positions on suffering; Caroline's April 26 claim is a good starting point. - **Sweet Honey in the Rock discography and liturgical use** — opened 2026-04-27; stub entity created; deeper discography and worship-planning applications TBD. - ~~[[Covenant Renewal Worship]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-05.** Full concept page: Exodus 19–24 five-movement shape, presider-as-herald, source gaps. - ~~[[C. Peter Wagner]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-02.** Full entity: Fuller Seminary, second-Reformation theory, International Coalition of Apostles, seven mountains dominionism. - ~~[[IHOPKC]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-01.** Full entity page written. - ~~[[Apostolic Authority]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-01.** Full concept page written. - [[Mike Bickle]] — new stub 2026-05-01; IHOPKC founder; full development pending primary-source ingest. - ~~[[Five-Fold Ministry]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-02.** Full concept page: Eph. 4:11 three-tradition reading, NAR governance hierarchy, structural accountability gap, worship-theology connection. - ~~[[Musical Sacramentality]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-05.** Full concept page: Lim/Ruth/Ingalls/Hobbs scholarly frame; Reformed and progressive critiques; pastoral-exclusion implications. - ~~[[Word-and-Table Liturgy]]~~ — **closed 2026-05-05.** Full concept page: fourfold mainline shape; UCC practice; song-slot implications; DEIB lens.